Federalism key to ecology – strong state role is necessary to avoid one size fits all approach
Sims, Charles et al, 2-16-2023, Department of Economics and Howard H. Baker Jr. Center for Public Policy @University of Tennessee, "Leveraging federalism for flexible and robust management of social‐ecological systems," besjournals, https://besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/pan3.10458 -- MoState JG
Ecological federalism highlights how the relative merits of state and federal management critically depend on features of the ecological and social systems. Disparate views over the relative merits of state versus federal management may reflect different perceptions of the spatiotemporal dynamics and critical biological and social heterogeneities that characterize the SES, instead of intractable political beliefs about the pros and cons of centralized government.
Figure 2 illustrates features of state-federal conflicts that ecological federalism is designed to address (see Supporting Information for details). In this pictorial model, the ecological system is defined by habitat patches, linkages between patches due to movement of organisms (animals, plants and viruses) and productivity or other gradients indicate that patches vary in their ability to support the organism. The ecological system spans two states whose residents value the ecosystem services produced from the SES and move between states. Each state can choose management that reflects the ecological system in their state and the values held by their residents. The greater the difference in the SES in the two states, the greater the difference in management chosen. However, absent interstate management conventions, state-level managers often ignore how their management affects neighbouring states. Federal management accounts for these spillovers between states but is forced to apply uniform, one-size-fits-all management in both states that ignores the differences in the SES in the two states. Federal level control with state-specific strategies developed in conjunction with the states allows for the coordination that federal management provides while incorporating local know-how into those coordinated management strategies. However, this type of regionally differentiated, perfectly informed, federal management is the exception rather than the rule. The federal government may have more resources and capacity than the states but typically not to the degree that customized management plans are created for each state. For a formalized model capturing many of these aspects of ecological federalism in a marine context, see Sanchirico et al. (2020).