State management is key to social environmental systems
Sims, Charles et al, 2-16-2023, Department of Economics and Howard H. Baker Jr. Center for Public Policy @University of Tennessee, "Leveraging federalism for flexible and robust management of social‐ecological systems," besjournals, https://besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/pan3.10458 -- MoState JG
2 | A SPEC TS OF SES THAT FAVOUR STATE OVER FEDERAL MANAGEMENT
1. Ecological heterogeneity: The quantity and quality of habitat as well as the resulting portfolio of organisms vary across states. State agencies that manage the environment, wildlife, and diseases have individuals stationed throughout the state to monitor habitat conditions and organism abundance. State governments tailor management to this localized information. While federal agencies collect and process data relevant to the management of SES, much of this information is readily available to local governments.
2. Social heterogeneity: States also vary with respect to the composition of their economies and the environmental preferences held by their residents. There are two reasons state management will be more aligned with local economies and public opinion. First, residents can move to states that provide the level of environmental attributes they desire. Second, there is often a stronger relationship between local government officials and their constituents relative to federal officials. State agencies often argue that they can catalyse collaborative efforts among local stakeholders better than their federal counterparts.
3. Natural laboratories: Management at the local level creates what Justice Brandeis called ‘laboratories of democracy’ that allow state governments to experiment with different management approaches. The California effect, whereby stricter California standards eventually spread to other states, is an example of the state laboratory concept in action (McNabb, 2013). Because diverse states may learn less from each other, ecological and social heterogeneity can diminish the benefits of having states experiment with different policy approaches. A constantly evolving patchwork of rules and regulations can also create confusion and uncertainty, especially when responding to rapidly changing conditions.