It’s not good for warming – quite the opposite in fact.
Salla Kalaniemi et. al 12-01-2020 ( Salla Kalaniemi and Jukka Heionen - University of Iceland, Faculty of Civil and Environmental Engineering. Juudit Ottelin and Seppo Junnila - Aalto University, Department of Built Environment. "Downscaling consumption to universal basic income level falls short of sustainable carbon footprint in Finland" Published in ScienceDirect. Accessed 06-19-2023. URL: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1462901119315333#abs0005) MSUCB
The carbon footprint at the UBI consumption level is on average 4.8 tCO2-eq, which is 49 % lower than the average carbon footprint in Finland. However, adding the governmental consumption and investments components to the UBI carbon footprint increases it to around 6.2 tCO2-eq, which is higher than the global average or “fair share”. Furthermore, the results illustrate that even a cutdown in the consumption levels in Finland down to the UBI level would not be enough to reach sustainable lifestyles considering the 1.5- or 2-degree climate targets in the long run. Innovations to decrease the GHG-intensity of consumption are needed as well. The results emphasize the need for low-carbon solutions for housing, nutrition, and travelling for all income classes. Economic growth has been and still is based on extensive utilization of fossil fuels. This has led to suggestions to build an alternative economic system based on degrowth. However, the results of our study raise the question on how to run a welfare state like Finland, with a large public sector and a wide variety of public goods and heavily subsidized semi-public goods, and have funding for new technologies to tackle the climate change in a degrowth economy. Nonetheless, in the light of the results of the study, it is equally difficult to see how continuous economic growth could be reconciled with 1.5- or 2-degree climate targets.