Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Increased consumption is a barrier.

MacNeill, T., & Vibert, A. (2019). Universal Basic Income and the Natural Environment: Theory and Policy. Basic Income Studies, 14(1). doi:10.1515/bis-2018-0026 MSUCB

There is reason to be concerned that a universal basic income could negatively affect the ecosystem. This point has been acknowledged by most theoretical research on the relation between BIG and the environment (Andersson, 2010; Boulanger, 2010), and all of the BIG advocates we consulted for this research recognized this potential issue as well. Recent studies have found that the environmental impacts of nations consistently rise with per capita income (Aşıcı & Acar, 2016; Uden, Salhuddin, Alam, & Gow, 2017). Income has also been found to be the main determinant of greenhouse gas emissions on an individual and household level. This income effect is so strong that it tends to statistically overwhelm pro-environment behavioral change even for those who self-identify as eco-conscious (Ivanova et al., 2018). This implies that it is not how we consume that determines the bulk of our personal environmental impact, but how much we consume. This is concerning since our total consumption is strongly tied to income. Furthermore, the marginal propensity to consume (MPC) – the amount of each additional dollar of income we use for consumption instead of savings – is lower for those who are on the high end of a country’s wealth distribution (Carroll, Slacalek, Tokuoka, & White, 2017). These understandings lead to an uncomfortable insight regarding the potential environmental impact of basic income strategies. That insight is that even if basic income were enacted via a direct redistribution of income from the wealthiest quintiles to the poorest with no net increase in total income per capita, we could still expect a negative environmental impact via increased consumption due to differentials in the MPC. This tension between poverty eradication and environmental degradation is so troublesome that it has been acknowledged in a discussion paper by OXFAM – one of the world’s largest non-governmental poverty reduction organizations (Raworth, 2012). The paper argues that poverty alleviation that is achieved without considering environmental consequences would push the biosphere beyond the limits necessary to sustain human civilization as we currently know it. Hubacek, Baiocchi, Feng, and Patwardhan (2017) report a similar finding regarding carbon emissions. Eradicating poverty through a basic income guarantee is not exactly the same as reducing it via economic growth. However, there have been no studies on the relation between basic income and consumption, so we must assume that consumption-based impacts would be similar to other forms of poverty reduction all other things being equal. A useful study has been produced on the consumption impacts of Alaska Permanent Fund (APF) annuities. APF annuity payments are not strictly a basic income program since they are not large enough to assure that basic needs are covered. They are a universal income supplement, however, as they are yearly dividend checks based on investment returns from the APF (which was originally establish with oil royalties). This annuity, which is usually approximately $2000, is distributed to every Alaskan citizen. The only published journal article on consumption and the APF has found that the MPC related to the APF is no different from that of any other form of income in all US states (Hsieh, 2003). The study finds that income from the APF increases individual consumption irrespective of the income bracket to which the individual belongs. A later book on the same topic reiterated these findings (Goldsmith, 2012). Thus, if we can take evidence from the APF fund as an exemplar of what to expect from consumption via a BIG, we can expect significant ecological impacts through increased overall consumption.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.