Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

--Afghanistan, Arab Spring, JCPOA, Paris all thump hegemonic power and show the decline of the ILO

Odeh 21 – Nabeel, a political researcher and an opinionist. He works at TRT as a Senior Producer. His works are interested in global affairs, foreign policy analysis, and digital politics. He is a regular TV commentator and lecturer. He is a PhD Candidate in International Relations in Kadir Has University. “U.S Withdrawal from Afghanistan: Only the Latest Proof of the Liberal Order’s Decline”, Al Sharq Strategic Research, https://research.sharqforum.org/2021/10/12/u-s-withdrawal-from-afghanistan-only-the-latest-proof-of-the-liberal-orders-decline/, 10-12-2021

As the last United States’ soldier left Afghanistan on August 30, the world witnessed one of the latest American foreign policy fiascos in the Middle East and Central Asia. The attempt of the United States (US) to construct a democratic and liberal state in its own image, failed. President Joe Biden declared following the withdrawal from Afghanistan that the U.S. mission in Afghanistan was not about spreading democracy or liberal order in the country, but fighting terrorism. The president’s downplaying of Afghanistan’s value-based intervention is only the newest piece of evidence of the waning of the U.S. policy of liberal interventionism, and a clear sign of the decline of liberal hegemony. This decline, however, does not entail the collapse of the global liberal order built on democratic value, human rights, free trade, and interdependency. The liberal order will stay as the fundamental framework of U.S. foreign policy.

However, the decision-makers in Washington are shifting from liberal interventionism (e.g., replacing illiberal regimes with democratic governments that adopt liberal principles and respect human rights) to a realist foreign policy, especially in response to the challenge imposed by rising powers such as China and Russia. This new shift in perspective will be reflected in international politics in three interrelated and interwoven areas: balance of power, arms race, and reformulating alliances, which can be considered as the fundamental principles of realism.

The Liberal Order in Global Politics

It can be argued that the first modern version of the value-based liberal order materialized in Europe after the Napoleonic wars. The so-called Concert of Europe reflected some of the liberal order’s foundational principles, as competitors sought to maintain overall stability by consensus and meeting on a common ground of shared values. As Kissinger argued, there was not only a physical equilibrium, but a moral one. Power and justice were in sustainable harmony. The immediate outcome of this transformation was an apparent reduction in the use of force.[i]

The Concert of Europe was successful in keeping the peace in Europe for nearly one hundred years. Besides some minor wars, such as the Crimean war, no major war occurred between the Great powers in Europe during that time, until the first World War (WWI). However, under the ashes of the war, the second phase of the international liberal order was soon to be born.

Exhausted by WWI, Europe would soon be eclipsed by a new power from beyond the oceans, the United States of America. The U.S. President Woodrow Wilson traveled across the Atlantic, carrying with him a vision of a new liberal order where human rights and democratic institutions occupied a pivotal position. Wilson believed that the balance of power and the arms race embedded in the European-made international order had made the war inevitable. To remedy this, he suggested building an order in which states would accept enforceable legal restrictions on their domestic and international conduct.

This gave birth to the League of Nations at the Treaty of Versailles. Wilson wanted the League to be an organization where powers sought to solve their disputes through consensus. However, the man driven by a utopian dream of a peaceful liberal order would ultimately die in grief after failing to convince his fellow Americans to abandon their isolationism and ratify the Treaty of Versailles to allow the US to become a member of the League.

Nevertheless, with Franklin D. Roosevelt’s advent to power and the end of the catastrophic World War Two (WWII) the Wilsonian world order finally formulated the principles that have guided international relations ever since. This order was echoed in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and conducted according to rules established by institutions such as the United Nations, the International Court of Justice, and the World Trade Organization[ii]. The liberal order rests on the maxim that states should pursue their interests through cooperation and mutual assistance.

Liberal philosophers believed that spreading democratic values and liberal principles such as freedom, cooperation, interdependence, human rights, and free trade order would transform the international system into an international society where states are subjected to supra-national binding laws and negotiated norms as a reference to address their disputes.

The Cold War, which erupted immediately after WWII, reinforced the need for strengthening and expanding the liberal order. The so-called containment policy, which defined the U.S. foreign Policy during the entire Cold War era and aimed to encircle the Soviet Union and fight communism, or the “Evil Empire,” as President Ronald Reagan called it, required a proactive policy from the world’s leading liberal democracies to work together and maintain a free and open system with multilateral cooperation anchored in coalitions.

The Liberal Hegemony

The Cold War’s end and the Soviet Union’s collapse was described as a liberal moment, the moment of the end of history when liberal values and democracy triumphed over totalitarianism. Both the George H. W. Bush and Clinton administrations would work to create a “new order;” an order where self-determination, the rule of law between and within countries, liberal economics, and the protection of human rights prevailed. The global order transformed into a unipolar system dominated by only one hegemonic liberal-super power. For the first time in modern history, the United States enjoyed a free hand to shape the world under liberal values. During that time, Russia was too weak to challenge the new liberal wave, and China was still making its way out of the crisis of Mao’s Great Leap. It was the moment of “liberal hegemony,” as Washington’s elite took liberal hegemony as an ambitious strategy to turn as many countries as possible into liberal democracies, while fostering an open international economy and building formidable international institutions. In essence, the United States sought to remake the world in its own image.[iii]

Similar to the ambitious Marshall Plan that was formulated to save Western Europe from falling into the clutches of communism after WWII, the United States and the European Union alike rushed to expand eastward and bring Eastern European states, formerly Soviet provinces, into Western influence. Not only that, but the United States quickly expanded the umbrella of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) to include many countries, such as Poland, that were previously subject to the communist orbit. These moves angered Russia, which gained the confidence to respond when Putin took power. Over time, this policy led to the outbreak of the Ukraine crisis, which claimed hundreds of dead and missing and put the entire security and stability of Europe at stake.

Generally speaking, liberal principles and democratization were the driving force behind this policy. Since some ideas like “democratic peace” gained significant momentum, the political elites believed that the only way to maintain the West’s security and stability came through spreading the principle of human rights and liberal norms. This belief was based on the “Democratic peace theory,” the belief that democratic and liberal states do not fight each other, but instead peacefully coexist and solve their disputes.

The United States used the same liberal cliché to justify waging its wars on Afghanistan and Iraq. Although September 11 shook the United States’ pride and dignity and unleashed its revenge, liberal-driven foreign policy still prevailed over its discourse. The main narrative used to justify the invasions was the liberation of the Afghani and Iraqi peoples from the iron grip of Saddam-like tyrants and radical Islamists. However, the Iraq war was arguably the first nail in liberal hegemony’s coffin. The Bush administration’s “With-us-or-against-us” approach ruined the multilateralism that the United Stated had built for decades and put it at odds with some of its closest allies such as France and Germany, who both rejected the war.

U.S. foreign policy: A departure from liberal interventionism

In addition to the 2003 Iraq war, several other factors contributed to the waning of liberal hegemony. The rise of other illiberal countries on the international stage, such as China and Russia, and their remarkable successes in both economics and politics, the rise of global terrorism, and the spreading of transnational crises such as the 2008 global financial crisis and the Coronavirus pandemic all contributed. This is in addition to the global rise of populism, of which Trump’s victory in the 2016 elections and Britain’s exit from the European Union (Brexit) are only its most prominent manifestations. Needless to say, the top policy on the populists’ agenda was to build walls and encourage isolationism and protectionism, breaking with their country’s liberal political tradition.

Moreover, the flaw of the liberal order is reflected in liberal states’ failure to coordinate and cooperate in addressing some of the striking global crises such as global warming or such results of advanced technological development like disinformation campaigns and fake news. However, even more shockingly, those liberal regimes failed to support the new democratic transition process in third-world countries such as Egypt and Tunisia after the Arab uprisings. Most Western liberal powers, for example, recognized the 2013 military coup in Egypt against a freely and fairly elected president and in utter hypocrisy prioritized their security over liberal principles.

This decline of the liberal hegemony was discernible in Obama’s “leading-from-behind policy”[iv], and Trump’s national isolationism, withdrawing his country from many international agreements and treaties, such as the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) on Iran’s nuclear program or the Paris Accord in fighting climate change.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.