Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Moreso, it decreases productivity.

Jacob Dowell 3-8-2019. (Jacob Dowell is an economics student particularly interested in the Austrian school of thought and its monetary theory., . "Andrew Yang’s Math Doesn’t Add Up on Universal Basic Income." No Publication. Web. accessed 6-19-2023 < https://fee.org/articles/andrew-yang-s-math-doesn-t-add-up-on-universal-basic-income/ >.)MSUCB

Efficient Employment, Not Enjoyable Employment A common argument against UBI is that it will incentivize people not to look for work. Yang answers this criticism, saying that $12,000 per year will still not be a good enough living for most people, so people will still be incentivized to get jobs and contribute to production. However, there are still marginal effects at play that can add up to huge changes: 1) It decreases the incentive for workers to quickly find new employment once they’re out of a job, and 2) it decreases their sensitivity to income differences between jobs. The increased time between jobs means there will be lower employment at any given time and, therefore, less production. And the decreased sensitivity to higher incomes means people will be more likely to do less productive work for the sake of enjoyment. While it may be desirable for workers to balance their income needs and their work preferences, a UBI would skew choices towards enjoyable work rather than efficient or productive work. Yang even admits this: “UBI increases art production, nonprofit work and caring for loved ones.” While these may be admirable activities, Yang is forgetting to consider the opportunity costs associated with them. While people will be more inclined to make art, write novels, and work less, the amount of needed goods in society will decline. This may be a worthwhile tradeoff to some, but when the main stated goal is to help those in poverty, producing less clothing and food is not going to achieve the desired ends. Andrew Yang does bring up some admirable points about a UBI avoiding the welfare cliff and reducing bureaucracy. However, the overall greater expansion of the government, the even more massive resource transfer from savers to consumers, and the productivity-reducing effects on labor all toll to a huge loss for the economy in the long run.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.