Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

It undermines collective institutions.

MacNeill, T., & Vibert, A. (2019). Universal Basic Income and the Natural Environment: Theory and Policy. Basic Income Studies, 14(1). doi:10.1515/bis-2018-0026 MSUCB

Canadian Indigenous leaders consulted for this research, and present at NABIG, were also concerned about the environmental problems associated with increased consumption. In addition, they were concerned that environmental protection could be undermined if a BIG were to be implemented in a way that undermined collective institutions and indigenous culture. The North Shore Tribal Council (NSTC) surveyed members of 34 First Nations in Northern Ontario, Canada as part of a community consultation on basic income. Despite promises of more money per person, the idea of direct cash transfers from a provincial government to individual did not resonate well with indigenous interviewees. The NSTC (2017) report expressed concerns that a BIG simply would represent “a shift from one form of dependency to another” (p. 2). The report continues:

[T]he historical shift to dependence on the welfare system has been a big factor in the now acknowledged undermining of First Nation culture and community… It has also been of concern that the welfare system is rooted in western “individualism” which runs counter to and has negatively affected First Nation’s as communities and the holistic “Anishnawbe way” of living (p. 2).

The Indigenous perspective, at least in the Canadian context, has long been that poverty alleviation requires investment in community resources and capacities. This, as argued in the NSTC report,

would ensure that the negative impacts that this dependence was inflicting on our cultures, communities, families and individual members be minimized; and that a holistic movement toward financial independence and individual, family and community healing be initiated… [M]any First Nations [recently] began a process of shifting the focus of their social assistance programs precisely from individualized hand out to community-based hand up. Which resulted in increasing success in terms of personal and community development to date (p. 2).

In a round-table on the indigenous perspective at NABIG, the four members of the NSTC that were present characterized the concept of basic income paid to individuals as “just another form of colonialism.” A community member quoted in the NSTC (2017) report argued that “the BI favours further individualization as opposed to the community-mindedness of many First Nations, and this community-mindedness needs to be constantly reinforced” (p. 9).

According to Richer, Wemigwans, Agawa Ge-Nad-Mo-Wit, and Boissoneau (2018) of the NSTC, the undermining of community that could come with a BI program also weakens environmental initiatives since these are rooted in cooperation and a collective culture. For example, a NSTC attempt to establish a distribution system of locally harvested, environmentally sustainable food depends on pooled community resources and cooperation on many levels. If social payments are transformed to cash installments received by individuals, such initiatives for sustainable community development could be undermined. This, claims Richer, could result in the increased import of expensive and environmentally damaging canned foods and potato chips instead of the establishment of the sustainable local food system toward which the NSTC aspires.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.