It can’t be solved without conditioning payment.
MacNeill, T., & Vibert, A. (2019). Universal Basic Income and the Natural Environment: Theory and Policy. Basic Income Studies, 14(1). doi:10.1515/bis-2018-0026 MSUCB
Conditions could be attached to the receipt of basic income funds. For example, part of basic income payments could be made in the form of vouchers for locally produced sustainable food, or public transit. Such policy suggestions do not appear in English-language academic journals, however Arnsperger (2015) does make an argument that a UBI be introduced as a complementary currency (which is exactly what a voucher is). Suggestion of conditions, however, were adamantly rejected by all experts consulted for this research at NABIG and via personal correspondence. This is not surprising, since, both BIGs and UBIs are premised on unconditionally. In reality, adding conditions changes the meaning of a BIG or UBI, necessitating the use of a different label – Conditional Minimum Income (CMI) will be used in the remainder of this paper.
For many advocates, a CMI would undermine a main premise of a UBI or BIG – a commitment to personal freedom of recipients and aversion to paternalistic behavior management on the part of the state. This value attached to personal freedom is not only an ethical decision. As Sheila Regehr (personal communication, June 25, 2018) points out, studies have shown a negative relationship between health outcomes and the restriction of the ‘sense of control’ people have over their lives (Rodin, 1986).
In addition, as Kourtney Koebel, points out, mandating green consumption as a condition for receipt of minimum incomes incorrectly “relies on the assumption that local markets [for green products] are easily accessible to recipients of the [minimum] income” (personal communication, June, 2018). There are also serious inequality concerns, as expressed by Chris Wiebe:
Ultimately, I don’t think that there should be environmental incentives/conditions attached to the basic income because I don’t think that environmental policies should target the poor. I think wealthier people are generally greater contributors to carbon emissions, and are more capable of paying more money for electric cars, organic/local food, or whatever products may be incentivized as part of an environmental policy (personal communication, July 3, 2018).
The Bolsa Família social welfare project in Brazil is an example of a CMI project that may have had some success, however. That program provides a cash transfer that is limited to impoverished families under the condition that their children attend school and take preventative health care steps such as vaccinations. Benefitting 48 million recipients by 2015, results of the Bolsa Família program are promising (ILO, 2015). Research and government reports have suggested that the program has increased preventative healthcare service utilization, improved health and nutrition, increased school attendance, and helped decrease poverty (Báez, Rodilla, Sharman, & Viveros, 2015; Shei, 2014; Wetzel, 2013).
With its exclusive focus on impoverished segments, family-based instead of individual-based distribution, and conditions around preventative health care and education, the Bolsa Família CMI is very different from a BIG or UBI. Although there is no evidence suggesting that Bolsa Família has reduced employment levels, its restriction to those in poverty does imply a built-in disincentive to work that is not present in the UBI. Additionally, the use of conditions does conflict with the emphasis on the normative value of freedom to which most BIG advocates adhere. Furthermore, the education and preventative health-based conditions of Bolsa Família are different from those required to make a basic income environmentally sustainable. Bolsa Família, therefore, may be too coercive to appeal to BI advocates, and lacks the environmental focus that a green CMI would imply. Nonetheless, it does provide a model that a green CMI project could emulate. Furthermore, depending on the absoluteness of the conditions – soft encouragement of environmental behaviour instead of strict enforcement – the line between a BI and a CMI may be blurred. This could lead to effective and innovative policy.