A UBI would make it impossible to do anything to combat warming.
Salla Kalaniemi et. al 12-01-2020 (Salla Kalaniemi and Jukka Heionen - University of Iceland, Faculty of Civil and Environmental Engineering. Juudit Ottelin and Seppo Junnila - Aalto University, Department of Built Environment. "Downscaling consumption to universal basic income level falls short of sustainable carbon footprint in Finland" Published in ScienceDirect. Accessed 06-19-2023. URL: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1462901119315333#abs0005) MSUCB
The UBI carbon footprint determined in this study, 4.8 tCO2-eq per capita, is notably smaller than the average carbon footprints for Finnish households in the comparison groups. Yet, they are still around three times as high as the long-term sustainable level suggested by O’Neill et al. (2018), but close to the global average. If the current global CO2 emissions (Le Quéré et al., 2018) were shared equally among all the people, everyone would have approximately a carbon budget of 5.6 tCO2 in 2017 following the IPCC (2018) 1.5-degree mitigation pathway. This number is quite close to the carbon footprint value estimated in this study for the UBI consumption level. However, this study only included the personal consumption component of carbon footprint excluding capital goods and governmental consumption, which have been shown to be significant globally and for European countries (e.g. Ivanova et al., 2016; Södersten et al., 2018; Heinonen et al., 2020).
In a recent study on Finland, Ottelin et al. (2018a) estimated that the final demand of households causes 77 % of the carbon footprint of total final demand in Finland. If the government consumption (14 %) and investments (5%), and the final demand of non-profit institutions (4%) are added to the UBI carbon footprint estimated in this study by following Ottelin et al. (2018a), the average carbon footprint at the UBI level would be 6.2 tCO2-eq per capita. However, Ottelin et al. show how the share of these emissions is larger in low-income than in high-income households. Thus, the UBI households probably use public services more than an average household, so the total average carbon footprint is likely to be more than 6.2 tCO2-eq., and thus higher than the global 1.5-degree mitigation pathway level. Moreover, to stay on the pathway, the emissions would need to be cut by approximately 10 % annually in addition to first reaching the current pathway level. Similarly, previous studies on the interaction between environmental and social Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) have shown that bringing the global population to a moderate expenditure level (still lower than the UBI level in this study), would lead to difficulties in achieving the climate targets unless additional mitigation measures are taken (Hubacek et al., 2017; Scherer et al., 2018).