Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

More reasons why it doesn’t work.

Najma Dayib 4-10-2021. (Graduate of the University of Pennsylvania with a Bachelor of Arts in Philosophy, Politics, and Economics . "Universal Basic Income: A Fundamentally Flawed Concept." Penn Political Review. Web. accessed 6-18-2023 < https://pennpoliticalreview.org/2021/04/universal-basic-income-a-fundamentally-flawed-concept/ >.)MSUCB

Universal Basic Income is a “guaranteed cash benefit that the government provides to all citizens.” In short, it is a baseline, non-withdrawable guaranteed income floor. As of 2020, no country has this form of UBI written into law. It is important to note that Switzerland, in 2016, rejected the first and only unconditional UBI proposal in the world. Although there is widespread public support for UBI, there seems to be a specific obstacle to implementation for governments all over the world. A typical economic case for UBI comes from concern about the advancement of technology in our increasingly modern society. In the book Give People Money, journalist Annie Lowrey suggests that it is not a matter of whether or not “self-driving cars and other automated technology would start putting people out of work;” it is rather a question of when. Universal Basic Income would provide those who lose their jobs with a much-needed safety net. Alternatives to Universal Basic Income Any form of UBI that is not universal is not truly UBI, but an alternative. A weaker proposal of UBI was introduced in 1960 when economist Milton Friedman proposed a Negative Income Tax. The Negative Income Tax (NIT) is similar to UBI in that it guarantees a certain amount of income to each household. Still, unlike UBI, this policy would mean that one’s cash transfer would gradually be taxed away as their income increased. The scholar Charles Murray, a strong proponent of UBI, argues for a more efficient system that would cut programs such as Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, and other social services and provide $13,000 per year to each citizen of the United States. Additionally, similar to NIT, those who earn more would receive less so that the least well-off in society could achieve a more equitable economic position. According to Murray, the current system we have in the United States is ineffective as there are many qualifications one must meet to receive government assistance. Murray argues that it would be more efficient to cut all assistance programs and institute a form of UBI that would genuinely benefit those in need. There are many other options available, as Table 1, provided by Kearney and Mogstad, shows. These include, but are not limited to, an annual transfer and conditional Basic Income: As the alternatives and table above showcase, a conditional — not universal — form of basic income would be preferable in almost all cases. The failure of UBI is the treatment of human capital as a secondary thought. In any credible and useful form, the basic income or annual transfer would allow the top 0.1% not to receive anything and the lowest 20% to receive the most. This is not a part of any true form of UBI. It is also important to note that there is significant disapproval for UBI from fiscal conservatives who would prefer that funds for social programs be diverted to other government programs. The U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO), through their audit, found severe government fiscal mismanagement. This mismanagement has led to a lack of financial support for all citizens and far too much support for the military and older adults who receive social security benefits. A new proposal supported by young Americans petitions that funds from the U.S. military budget be diverted to the home front and billions of tax dollars be returned to Americans through social programs. As of 2020, this has yet to be accomplished, as our current government is overwhelmingly composed of fiscally and socially conservative politicians vehemently opposed to this proposal. Given this reality, it is difficult to assess if UBI will ever be enacted. Projecting the Outcomes Before March of 2020, it was difficult to imagine what an implementation of UBI would look like. Then, over 22 million Americans filed for unemployment in the month of April alone. It’s important to note that the United States’ single $1200 conditional cash transfer to Americans during the COVID-19 pandemic cannot be considered a form of UBI. Though the United States failed to implement a long-lasting relief check for most of the country’s population, stimulus checks still garnered wide public approval. A recent poll conducted by OnePoll also demonstrated that, after receiving their first stimulus checks, 80 percent of those sampled believed that the economic impact payments should continue until the end of the pandemic. On the other hand, the Canadian COVID-19 Economic Response Plan, similar to plans in the majority of other countries facing economic crisis due to the pandemic, guaranteed checks for a larger portion of citizens than the U.S., with a plan to continue payments through the rest of the pandemic. Additionally, only six million Canadians filed for unemployment within April compared to the United States’ 22 million. Through the Canada Recovery Benefit (CRB), citizens who lost their jobs, faced income reduction, or were forced to stop working received $500 per week for up to 26 weeks. This recovery procedure is much closer to UBI than the United States’ response. Aside from the partisan divide between those within the Liberal Party who enacted the policy, and the Conservatives who argued that it lacked a commitment to fiscal restraint and failed to address the needs of “everyday Canadians,” most Canadian citizens were quite content with the package compared to the overwhelming disapproval in the United States. As the last few months have proven, UBI is not as disruptive to our normative system of government as one might assume. However, it is not enough. A consistent cash transfer alone will not remedy wealth and income inequality, the lack of access to adequate healthcare, and, overall, the government’s failure to redistribute tax dollars and provide a financial safety net. Our current system offers an overly complicated tax process, yet insufficient social benefits to account for many Americans’ difficulties. In the long term, UBI is similar to a form of symbolic redistribution. A genuinely universal UBI program would not be ideal for the economy as a whole, as it presents a short-term solution to more long-term problems. Furthermore, without a wealth tax or a modernized form of NIT, UBI could hurt the economy and the working class more than it would help. An alternative would accurately target the least well-off . Conclusion In conclusion, UBI has hardly progressed in concept since American revolutionary Thomas Paine originally proposed the idea in Agrarian Justice in 1797. The lack of implementation of UBI and the increasing complexity of the world’s economic systems tell us this: UBI is perceived as an idealistic, symbolic solution to income inequality that fails to address underlying issues. New policy proposals come mostly from former Democratic presidential candidate Bernie Sanders and Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (NY-14), who both identify as Democratic-Socialists. These progressive policies cover many aspects of social welfare: climate justice, Medicare, housing, and college for all, and eliminating student and medical debt. Thus, these policies provide a basic social safety net for Americans, while also offering a clear path for funding. All in all, UBI does not meet the same level of planning and support, rendering it a largely unrealistic approach. UBI would be an expensive and virtually useless program for the most vulnerable in our society—the poor, disabled, elderly, and youth.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.