Single payer collapses the stock market---destroys trillions in asset values
Caird ’17 (Lawrence Caird – former Hospital Administration Assistant and worked in Health Care Management, former employee in Public Affairs at the Veterans Administration, “Medicare For All would likely be a huge failure,” 20 September 2017, http://registerguard.com/rg/opinion/35974386-78/medicare-for-all-would-likely-be-a-huge-failure.html.csp)
You say, “What about the profits?” Profits are paid to stockholders, many of whom are people investing for their retirement. The balance is invested in the economy. Insurance companies, unlike the government, have to have assets to cover unanticipated costs.
How do you think 9/11 claims were paid? Insurance companies did not have that amount of cash on hand. They liquidated investments to get the cash. The investments of health insurance companies, if they were put out of business by this law, would probably be sold and the proceeds would be paid to stockholders. But the industries and real estate they invest in would suffer the loss of capital.
Beside losing the right to sue for losses, we would probably also lose the Affordable Care Act in the process. It is hard to defend one program while advocating for another.
It is impossible to estimate how much the stock market would tumble. Stock prices are based on the confidence of investors.
If the government can wipe out an entire industry because it does not like the way it is being run, hospital stocks, drug company stocks, medical supply stocks and medical equipment stocks would probably be affected. This could cause the stock market to crash, somewhere between what happened in 1929 and 2008. The losses to American families in retirement funds could possibly be in the trillions of dollars.