Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Won’t reduce administrative costs – likely to increase them because Medicare’s administrative costs have been more than private insurance.

Robert E. Moffit, Ph.D. Senior Research Fellow, Center for Health and Welfare Policy Aug 9, 2019 3 min read https://www.heritage.org/medicare/commentary/medicare-no-model-administrative-simplicity-or-efficiency

“Medicare for All” legislation pending in Congress would give Washington over American health care. It would abolish private and employer-based health coverage and replace it with a new, government-run health program. Its sponsors claim this would reduce administrative costs and produce huge savings. “Private insurance companies in this country spend between 12 and 18 percent on administration costs,” says Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt. “The cost of administering the Medicare program… is 2 percent. We can save approximately $500 billion a year just in administration costs.” Not so fast. Most independent analysts are reluctant to embrace such bold claims. Glenn Kessler, a fact-checker for The Washington Post backers of Medicare for All to be “cautious” in relying on “the administrative cost saving” as a talking point, and Politifact rated Senator Sanders’ statement as Comparisons between public and private sector administrative costs are tricky. Medicare and private insurance cover radically different populations: Medicare beneficiaries are generally older and sicker than those enrolled in private plans. Because Medicare beneficiaries’ utilize medical services at dramatically higher levels, the program’s administrative costs naturally account for a lower percentage of total program spending. However, as Dr. Robert Book, a senior fellow at George Mason University, measuring administrative cost per beneficiary, rather than as a percentage of total spending, shows that Medicare’s administrative cost has been historically higher than private insurance. Medicare is no model of administrative simplicity. The program is governed by tens of thousands of pages of rules, regulations, guidelines and related paperwork. Its structure, organization, payment and pricing and related rules—including coding, documentation and reporting requirements—are mind-numbingly detailed. This morass of bureaucratic complexity imposes high, albeit often hidden, costs, including administrative demands on harried doctors and other medical professionals who must daily comply with the program’s overbearing rules and paperwork under the penalty of law. These transactional costs—the mandatory reporting and the time, energy and effort required to satisfy these bureaucratic requirements—are very real. Writing for the Journal of the American Medical Association, researchers that, for American doctors, “…the time spent on administrative issues related to reporting clinical or quality data to government or other agencies is a major problem.”

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.