Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Plan massively reduces industry jobs ---that creates devastating economic ripple effects

Dave Kamper 17, Dave Kamper is a labor organizer in the Twin Cities., 5-28-2017, "Taking Single-Payer Seriously," Jacobin, https://www.jacobinmag.com/2017/05/single-payer-medicare-for-all-health-jobs

Has the time for Medicare for All finally arrived? Many on the Left certainly think so. “Various half-measures are not worth it,” physician and activist Adam Gaffney wrote a few weeks ago. “Single-payer is the alternative to the health care status quo.” This is not just idle chitchat. A January Pew Research survey found that 60 percent of Americans think the government “has a responsibility to make sure all Americans have health care coverage.” And a recent Morning Consult poll showed 44 percent of Americans backed a single-payer plan, much more than those who opposed it. Those are real numbers, and the Left has every reason to be excited that our arguments are gaining traction. But if we want to make Medicare for All a reality, we have an obligation to think through the consequences of effectively euthanizing an industry that many have come to rely on for employment. A Spending Machine The private health insurance industry is, as many have observed, one of the primary drivers of health care costs. We spend far more on health care than any other advanced capitalist country and end up with inferior health outcomes. The Affordable Care Act (ACA) kept that basic system in place. For all the talk of mandates and cost curves and exchanges, Obamacare massively increased spending in the health care system. When more people get health insurance, more people use health care. The Medicaid expansion and the subsidies for coverage on the individual market funnel tens of billions of additional dollars into insurance companies and health care providers every year. In 2014, the first year that the ACA was more or less in full force, net expenditures on health care rose 4.6 percent. In 2015, they jumped 5.6 percent. The same year, the federal government estimated that outlays would expand “1.2 percentage points faster than Gross Domestic Product” over the next decade. By 2025, it projected, health care would no longer make up one-sixth of the American economy. It would make up one-fifth. Much of this spending results in new jobs. From 2011 to 2016, overall job growth in the US sat at 8.3 percent, but the number of health care practitioners rose 15.8 percent. Nurse practitioner jobs increased 76 percent. Speech-language pathologist positions expanded by 29.6 percent. “Medical records and health information technicians” went up 58.6 percent. In the health insurance industry, “insurance claims and policy processing clerks” went up 11 percent. As long as the ACA fire hose keeps spraying money at the health care industry, jobs will balloon accordingly. If the water pressure drops, the consequences will be real and drastic, even if the overall result is more equitable and more affordable health care. Medicare for All wouldn’t just scrap Obamacare — it would uproot the entire industry. It would be a huge efficiency savings. But it would also be devastating in the short term for hundreds of thousands of working people whose only crime was getting a job at an insurance company, and the hundreds of thousands more who work as billing specialists for clinics and hospitals (the number of medical assistants shot up 44 percent between 2011 and 2016). Yes, the CEO of United Health Group made $101 million in 2011. But few of the 230,000 other people working for the company saw money like that. Bernie Sanders’s recently announced Medicare for All plan asserts that we “need a health care system that significantly reduces overhead, administrative costs, and complexity,” and projects that his plan would save $6 trillion over ten years. Those trillions — currently being sucked up by a bloated, profit-hungry industry — could do amazing things. Infrastructure. Education. Housing. Insurance for all, in and of itself, would be remarkable. But you don’t save $6 trillion just by getting rid of the insurance industry. The US has 35.5 MRI machines per million people. The UK, with its National Health Service, has 6.1. Single-payer Canada has 8.5. We don’t need as many as we have. We can deliver complete patient care with many fewer machines. But fewer machines means fewer manufacturing jobs, fewer technician jobs, less need for new construction for new facilities, and so on. And MRIs are just one facet of a huge health care system that will see efficiencies across the board in a single-payer system. The benefits of those efficiencies will be felt by all, the harms by few, but they will feel them hard. The effects of these changes would be highly local. Some of the campuses of large health insurance companies employ thousands. Shuttering them would be like shuttering a steel mill or auto factory — the shockwaves would reverberate through the whole community. Like laid-off autoworkers, employees of insurance companies would be pushed onto the job market with a set of skills and experiences unsuited to most other occupations. The color of their collar wouldn’t change that. And that disruption would have serious political effects. The 2016 election hinged on the Rust Belt, states like Michigan, Ohio, and Pennsylvania that used to be home to huge numbers of unionized, high-wage blue-collar jobs. As those industrial jobs disappeared, cities across the Midwest sustained hits from which they still haven’t recovered. The Democratic Party’s prescriptions — like trying to encourage fifty-year-old autoworkers to go back to community college to study IT — were both condescending and impractical. Many saw no reason to back a party that hadn’t done anything for them, and that left them exposed to the nativist economic nationalism of Trump. We can’t risk the same thing happening because of single-payer.

Massive job losses will result from the switch to Medicare for All

Pollin, Robert. (Distinguished University Professor of Economics and Co-Director, Political Economy Research Institute (PERI) University of Massachusetts-Amherst) “Economic Analysis of Medicare for All .” Political Economy Research Institute , 2018, peri.umass.edu/publication/item/1127-economic-analysis-of-medicare-for-all. accessed 6-28-23.

The transition out of the existing U.S. health care system into Medicare for All will entail formidable challenges. As we have discussed, there will be three major sets of issues to tackle: 1. The overall administrative and financial transition; 2. Changes in the fee structure and billable hours for physicians, along with increased demand for health care services; and 3. The displacement of workers now employed in both the private health insurance and health services industries. A wide range of problems—anticipated and unanticipated—will inevitably emerge in all three of these areas. We nevertheless conclude that a workable transition process is achievable. That is, the transition can be accomplished while maintaining: 1) a reasonably high level of administrative effectiveness; 2) a flow of revenues sufficient to cover all system-wide budgetary requirements; and 3) a just transition for workers and communities that will be negatively affected in the move from our existing health care system to Medicare for All. This is while the establishment of Medicare for All also advances towards accomplishing its fundamental purpose, i.e. providing universal access to decent health care for all U.S. residents. Delving a bit more into specifics, we have also concluded that this transition can be made workable while proceeding either within a longer or shorter time frame—that is, focusing on two examples we have reviewed, either within the four-year time frame proposed in the September 2017 draft of the Medicare for All bill or within a one-year period for accomplishing most of the necessary administrative and financial restructuring. There will be both costs and benefits through proceeding with either a longer or shorter transition period. But it will be useful here to briefly bring together here some of the major considerations that we have already discussed in this chapter. Among other sectors of the economy, the transition will heavily impact government health care bureaucracies, private insurance companies, businesses managing health insurance for their employees, individuals and families currently covered through private plans, hospitals, the practices of physicians and other providers, and workers who will face job displacement. A longer phase-in period offers the significant benefit of simply providing more time for each of these sectors to successfully implement the full range of transition tasks that they will encounter. But with respect to costs, the longer phase-in period will mean delays for businesses and households in receiving the health care cost savings that will accrue to them under Medicare for All. Under the four-year phase-in, businesses would also have to continue administering private coverage for their employees who were not yet eligible for Medicare for All. It will also certainly be problematic for the U.S. health care system to continue operating with a substantial degree of dependence on the private health insurance companies during a four-year phase-in. At that point, the private insurance companies would be facing a mandated termination of their operations within a few years. They would therefore have little to no incentive to deliver service at high quality levels during their final years in business. These relative benefits and costs of a four-year transition approach have their mirror image with a shorter phase-in framework. A one-year transition period is, of course, a compressed schedule for overhauling an ongoing $3.5 trillion operation—nearly 20 percent of the U.S. economy. At the same time, we have reviewed various types of credible evidence suggesting that this one-year time frame is workable. This includes the fact that, at present, roughly one-third of the U.S. population is already covered by public health insurance plans and two-thirds of the overall funding needed to finance Medicare for All will come from available public sources. We have also considered relevant precedents, including the initial establishment of the U.S. Medicare system in 1965-66 without benefit of modern information technologies, and the fact that nearly 4 million people are presently newly enrolling in Medicare each year. As we also saw, Taiwan successfully implemented a transition to its single-payer system in less than one year in 1994-95, also without access to current IT capacities. Medicare for All will increase overall demand for health care services. Indeed, this follows from the fundamental purpose of the system, to ensure that all U.S. residents have access to decent health care. At present, over one-third of all U.S. residents are either uninsured or underinsured. These population cohorts will therefore benefit substantially the faster they are able to receive access to care under Medicare for All. Moreover, as we have discussed, this increased demand for services should not create significant shortages in the supply of health care providers, even in the short run. This is primarily because, under Medicare for All, physicians will be able to substantially reduce the amount of time they now spend on administration and to correspondingly increase the time they can devote to patient care. This increase in billable hours will compensate physicians for the per-visit fee reductions many will experience under uniform Medicare-based provider rates. Nurses will be able to shift a major share of their overall workweek out of administration and into patient care. In particular, modest increases in the reliance on nurse practitioners and physician assistants should help physicians manage the increased demand for their services resulting from Medicare for All. It will also expand employment opportunities for nurse practitioners and physician assistants. In turn, this will also counteract the increasing problem of excess supply of qualified people in these fields. The implementation of Medicare for All will produce significant job losses for workers now employed in the private health insurance industry as well as administrative support staffers devoted to health insurance matters within the health care services industry. Providing fair levels of support and protections for these workers—including pension guarantees, 100 121 percent wage-replacement income, as well as retraining and relocation support—will need to be a major component of the overall transition process. These job losses will be experienced more sharply under a shorter transition phase-in. Efforts to support displaced workers will also be more demanding within a shorter time period. Overall then, again, there are costs and benefits associated with both a longer transition period, such as the four-year phase in proposed in the current Medicare for All bill, as well with a shorter transition, such as a one-year phase in. At the appropriate time, the relative strengths and weaknesses of both approaches, and well as others, will need to be explored more fully than is possible in this study.

Medicare for All destabilizes the insurance industry causing job loss.

Pradhan , Rachana.( Pradhan spent more than three years Inside Health Policy focusing on implementation of the Affordable Care Act. Prior to that, Pradhan worked at The Daily Progress in Charlottesville, Va., and spent most of her time covering city government) “Medicare for All’s Jobs Problem.” POLITICO, 25 Nov. 2019, www.politico.com/news/agenda/2019/11/25/medicare-for-all-jobs067781.accessed 6-29-23.

There are lots of health reform ideas that wrap themselves in the “Medicare for All” label, ranging from a single government-run system to plans that maintain a role for private insurance companies. But under the most ambitious schemes, millions of health care workers would be at least displaced if not laid off, as the insurance industry disappears or is restructured and policymakers work to bring down the costs of the system by reducing high overhead and labor costs. The reform proposals being promoted by Democratic presidential candidates have barely grappled with this problem. Initial research from University of Massachusetts economists who have consulted with multiple 2020 campaigns has estimated that 1.8 million health care jobs nationwide would no longer be needed if Medicare for All became law, upending health insurance companies and thousands of middle class workers whose jobs largely deal with them, including insurance brokers, medical billing workers and other administrative employees. One widely cited study published in the New England Journal of Medicine estimated that administration accounted for nearly a third of the U.S.’ health care expenses. Even if a bigger government expansion into health care left doctors, nurses, and other medical professionals’ jobs intact, it would still cause a restructuring of a sprawling system that employs millions of middle-class Americans. Claire Cohen, a Pittsburgh-based child psychiatrist, voted for Bernie Sanders, the architect of the most sweeping version of Medicare for All, in the 2016 Democratic presidential primary. She says the national discussion about single payer and its overwhelming focus on paying higher taxes or losing private insurance misses the point ― she argues individuals would see greater benefit from a health care system without premiums, copays and other costs that increasingly make health care out of reach. But the question about jobs, she says, is a “legitimate” issue ― one she says people haven’t completely thought through. “You don’t want to leave all these people in the lurch without jobs,” Cohen said.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.