Decline does not cause disputes.
Macdonald and Parent 18 – Paul, Political Science Professor at Wellesley College. Joseph, Political Science Professor at the University of Notre Dame. “Twilight of the Titans: Great Power Decline and Retrenchment”, University Press, pg. 61, 10.7591/cornell/9781501717093.001.0001, xx-xx-2018
Once declining powers get involved in a dispute, are they more likely to escalate? The evidence suggests not. Declining powers had an average hostility in their militarized disputes of 2.8, which compares to 2.9 for the baseline, a difference that is not statistically significant.46 Out of our sixteen cases of declining powers, seven had an average hostility that lay above the baseline in their militarized disputes, whereas seven had an average hostility that lay below the baseline. One partial exception to this null result may be small decliners, who had an average dispute hostility of 2.6. But in general, the typical behavior of declining powers appears to resemble that of their non-declining counterparts. They tend to display or threaten to display force, rather than actually use it.
Collectively, these three sets of findings provide sturdy evidence against preventive war theories. Far from being more likely to lash out aggressively, declining powers appear no more likely to initiate militarized disputes than the average power. Nor do declining powers appear more vulnerable to scavengers. Indeed, declining powers participate in fewer militarized disputes than their non-declining counterparts. The evidence also calls into question predictions that declining powers favor do-or-die schemes. Rather, declining powers do not get involved in disputes that escalate to higher levels of hostility than the average power.