Medicare for All collapses state discretion and destroys federalism.
Sara R. Collins and Jeanne M. Lambrew July 19 2019 Federalism, the Affordable Care Act, and Health Reform in the 2020 Electionhttps://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/fund-reports/2019/jul/federalism-affordable-care-act-health-reform-2020-election
Medicare for All. At the other end of the federalism spectrum, a Medicare for All approach, which would leave virtually no discretion to states, would be expected to increase coverage nationally and significantly reduce state variation in coverage and access. Given its near-automatic enrollment of all residents, it would go the farthest in moving states like Texas closer to the front of the pack. However, its uniform approach might not eliminate regional differences in access to coverage, which persist under Medicare. Additionally, it would stifle innovation in states like California, which have been performance leaders in marketplace and Medicaid expansion implementation.