The effect on economy is significant – a 1 percent increase in coverage translates into 0.3 percent growth by increasing productivity and labor supply.
Malloy et al 16 [Liam Malloy, University of Rhode Island. Shanna Pearson-Merkowitz, University of Rhode Island. Irwin Morris, University of Maryland.] “State-Sponsored Health Insurance and State Economic and Employment Growth” Politics and Policy Volume 44, Issue 5, October 2016, Pages 945–975 (doi.org/10.1111/polp.12176)
Economic Growth and Health Insurance Rates in the U.S. States Table 3 presents the GMM regression results for the U.S. state panel dataset without spending. The main finding is that health insurance coverage for the working age population (18-65 year olds) has a positive effect on economic growth. Column (i) shows that a 1 percentage point increase in coverage for the working age population is associated with an increase of 0.306 percentage points of contemporaneous annual growth. Column (ii) breaks out coverage by private versus public health-care plans and we can see that the positive effect is mainly due to public coverage (the coefficient on private coverage is positive but insignificant and much smaller). In column (iii) we break this out further to distinguish between Medicaid, Medicare, and Military coverage. They are all significant (at least at the 10 percent level) and of similar size, although military coverage appears to have the largest effect. This is not surprising given the federal spending that comes along with having a large military population in the state. Coverage for those under 18, who by and large are not in the workforce, is not significant and the economic effect is quite small in all three of these regressions. Keep in mind that these regressions only measure the contemporaneous effect of health insurance coverage on economic growth rather than the long-run effect that might be present in covering children who may grow up to be healthier and more productive workers. Unfortunately, our dataset is not long enough to capture these effects. Our dataset also allows us to look at the effect of health-care spending on economic growth. We have the data broken down by type (private spending, Medicare spending, and Medicaid spending) and as a percent of the states’ GDP and on a per-enrollee basis.20 Increased spending on health care may drive economic growth, especially if health care is a driver of productivity growth. Conversely, higher health-care spending will decrease spending in other industries which may decrease growth if those other industries are more productive. Our results, presented in Table 4, show that personal health-care spending, whether measured as a percent of GDP (column (i)) or per capita (column (ii)) has a significant negative effect on growth. This implies that private health-care spending, which was growing much faster than GDP in our sample, is a significant drag on growth. Government health-care spending, on the other hand, has a positive effect on growth, especially Medicaid spending, although this is not always statistically significant. Our regressions in Table 4 include health insurance coverage variables. These become insignificant in columns (i) and (ii) where private and government coverage are lumped together, but are (weakly) significant when we break out coverage by private versus public in columns (iii) and (iv). Once again it is government coverage for the working age population that has a positive effect on contemporaneous economic growth. In column (v), which includes spending both as a percent of GDP and per capita (or per-enrollee) costs, total Medicaid spending as a percent of GDP continues to have a positive effect on growth while personal health-care spending as a percent of GDP has a significantly negative effect. The per capita and per-enrollee variables all have negative coefficients, but are not statistically significant.21 Another test that may help distinguish between the relative impacts of potential labor supply and health-care innovation on growth is to use total employment growth22 as our dependent variable as opposed to economic growth. Table 5 repeats the regressions of Table 3 with employment growth as the dependent variable and health insurance coverage as the main independent variables of interest. These results mirror the earlier results with total coverage of the working age population, in column (i), increasing employment growth (while controlling for the employment to population ratio). Column (ii) shows that this is due to government coverage as opposed to private health insurance coverage, and column (iii) shows the effects are due equally to Medicaid and Medicare coverage. These results strongly imply that providing health coverage to this vulnerable population (mainly the poor, the disabled, and the working elderly) increases their labor supply significantly.