Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Public health care spends less on administration than private insurance

Adam Gaffney, 5-12-22, (Adam Gaffney holds a medical degree and a Masters of Public Health. He is an assistant professor at Harvard Medical School, has published a book on historical medical access, and is highly active in discussions about medical policy.), “Medicare for All: Protecting Health, Saving Lives, Saving Money”, Senate Budget Committee, https://www.budget.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Adam%20Gaffney%20-%20Witness%20Testimony%20-%20US%20Senate%20Budget%20Committee.pdf, da: 06-26-2023, //mduff

In 2017, 34% of healthcare spending was devoted to administration in the US — approximately twice the proportion spent on administration in Canada’s single-payer national health insurance system. Much of this administrative expense stems from the wasteful bureaucracy inherent to private health insurance. Compared to a public insurer like traditional Medicare, private insurers inflict numerous added costs, including profits for shareholders, bloated executive salaries, product and benefit design, marketing, and burdensome processes for disputing claims (needed to maximize profit). The CBO estimates that private insurance plans take 16.0% of their premium revenues for their overhead and profit. The National Health Expenditure Accounts (NHEA) historical year data provides a slightly lower estimate of 12% (author’s calculation; 2018-2020 three-year moving average). Publicly-funded plans operated by private health insurance companies, e.g. Medicare Advantage, have overhead similar to those of other commercial health insurance plans. An estimate from the Government Accountability Office (GAO) put overhead for Medicare Advantage plans (inclusive of profit) at 13.6% in 2011. Today, the share may even be higher. Using the 2020 NHEA estimate of Medicare net private health insurance costs (i.e. overhead) of $63.4 billion divided by 2020 estimates from the 2021 report of Medicare Trustees of $42227 in Medicare Part C +D spending gives a similar overhead of 15%. In comparison, traditional Medicare has an overhead of approximately 2% (author’s calculation from the 2021 Medicare Trustees report); a similar proportion is estimated by the CBO for overhead under Medicare for All. Nations with national health insurance systems, including Canada, have a similarly low insurance overhead. In other words, reducing insurance overhead of the overall US healthcare system to that of traditional Medicare could unlock enormous savings — funds that can then be used to cover the costs of a generous coverage expansion for all. And indeed, the CBO has estimated savings from such a reduction in insurance costs at over $400 billion annually. Some analyses have come to lower savings because they incorrectly projected that overhead of a single-payer system would be more than three times higher than that projected by the CBO.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.