Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Turn---single payer will trim unneeded specialty positions and adequately compensate primary care. Primary care solves better and more cheaply.

Dr. Jerald Winakur 16, Dr. Winakur practiced internal and geriatric medicine for 36 years and is an associate faculty member at the Center for Medical Humanities and Ethics at the University of Texas Health Science Center at San Antonio., June 2016, “A Single-Payer System Can Save Primary Care,” Caring For The Ages, Volume 17, Number 7, http://www.caringfortheages.com/pb/assets/raw/Health%20Advance/journals/carage/JULY_2016.pdf

The problem with Medicare, of course, is the fee schedule itself. It vastly undervalues the work that doctors like me do. At the same time, it overvalues the work of my sub-specialty colleagues. The fee schedule favors technology over touch, performing procedures over spending time with patients. Of course, Medicare didn’t pick numbers out of the air; the fee schedule has been unduly influenced by the richer and thus more powerful doctor groups that sit on the American Medical Association’s resource update committee. This secretive and specialist-stacked assemblage advises Medicare on setting procedural fees. Ninety percent of such advice finds its way into the schedule, which is why an otolaryngologist makes more money to clean wax out of an ear than a geriatrician gets for evaluating an 85-year-old woman who comes into the office after having had a “little spell.” I believe that a vibrant system of primary care is essential for patient wellbeing. Every one of us needs and deserves enough space for an unrushed visit and a thorough physical examination by someone who knows us and our unique circumstance and is available across time and sites of care to minister and to advocate. Patients who are under the watchful eye of a primary care physician receive less expensive medical care without sacrificing the quality of that care. Medicare may track every test I order, every consultant to whom I make a referral, every hospital admission I initiate. But Medicare has never known how many patients I saved from inappropriate testing and consultations, ED referrals, hospital stays, and LTC placements. And aside from the dollars saved, my patients have been spared many needless procedures and the associated morbidity these entail. Single-Payer Solution There is one simple way to accomplish this. A single-payer plan can tinker with the fee schedule and fi nally make it financially remunerative for young doctors to once again pursue primary care. Increase the routine doctor visit reimbursement codes signifi cantly — enough to allow primary care physicians to actually spend face-to-face time with patients. The 7-minute visit is unsatisfactory to patients and demoralizing to doctors. Undoubtedly, this is contributing to the greater than 50% burnout rate for primary physicians. Changing to a single-payer system will not require an infusion of more dollars into the system. It will require a rebalancing of what a sane single-payer system pays for the thousands of over-compensated procedure codes that currently exist. Yes, my specialty colleagues will be unhappy with such a proposal. But unless they want to take over the 24/7 responsibility of caring for the soon-tobe 75 million seniors with their complex medical histories, polypharmacy, and fraught social needs, my specialist friends should yield to the reality that our current system of crumbling primary care cannot accomplish this task without major change.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.