Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Enhancing access and reducing inefficiencies and fragmentation saves money and boosts businesses

Cathy Schoen February 2, 2016 [Senior Scholar in Residence at the New York Academy of Medicine. She is the former executive director of the Commonwealth Fund Council of Economic Advisors and former senior vice president for Policy, Research, and Evaluation at The Commonwealth Fund, as well as the former research director of the Fund’s Commission on a High Performance Health System.] “The Affordable Care Act and the U.S. Economy” The Commonwealth Fund http://www.commonwealthfund.org/~/media/files/publications/fund-report/2016/feb/1860_schoen_aca_and_us_economy_v2.pdf?la=en

Although the number of people working full-time has risen well above pre-recession levels, there has been little improvement in average weekly pay or income for working families. Average wages in the private sector have barely kept up with inflation over the past five years. More recently, inflation-adjusted pay has picked up—with a one-year gain of 2.1 percent through October 2015—but this likely reflects lower energy costs for consumers (Exhibit 9).7 With no significant increases in wages for the majority of the nation’s workforce, particularly middle- and low-wage employees, there has been little or no improvement in median incomes since 2010.8,9 This represents a continuation of a longer-term pattern that began well before the recession. By 2007, before the recession hit, median income adjusted for inflation was below the level in 1999.10 Even in relatively tight labor markets, median incomes have for two decades failed to keep up with inflation. The gains from economic growth have instead accrued mainly to the top 5 percent of the income distribution.11 By 2015, a spreading movement to increase the minimum wage has started to raise the wage floor in labor markets. Reflecting this and perceived mounting upward pressures on wages, the CBO, among other forecasters, predicts that wages will pick up in future years as employers compete for new workers.12 HEALTH CARE COSTS: SLOWDOWN IN GROWTH EXTENDS TO A FIFTH YEAR A key goal of the Affordable Care Act is to slow growth in the costs of health care while enhancing access and health outcomes. With abundant evidence of waste and inefficiency throughout the U.S. health system, the ACA’s framers looked to incentivize providers and payers to achieve better health outcomes at lower cost.13 Lower cost inflation would reduce the federal government’s costs for Medicare and the insurance expansion, make private insurance more affordable, and free up private and public resources for other needs. Critics worried, however, that ACA’s tools for addressing cost were relatively weak and that setting standards for health insurance benefits might increase the cost of coverage. Contrary to critics’ fears, the slowdown in health care spending that began during the recession, before passage of the ACA, has continued well into the economic recovery. As illustrated by Exhibit 10, growth in national health expenditures slowed to the rate of overall economic growth for four years, from 2009–10 through 2013–14. This represents a break from the pattern seen when the economy has emerged from past recessions. Indeed, the slower pace of private as well as Medicare spending through 2014 has led to multiple revisions of the CBO’s federal budget projections. As employers have spent more on jobs and less on health benefits than initially forecast, and as Medicare and insurance expansion costs have come in lower than expected, the CBO has revised upward its federal revenue projections and lowered its projections of federal health care spending. This in turn has led to downward revisions of projected federal deficits (March 2015 and August 2015). Of special significance is the reduction in Medicare spending per beneficiary, which is now below the rate of inflation. According to the CBO’s most recently revised projection, Medicare spending by 2020 will be $186 billion below the level projected in January 2010, for a 10-year cumulative savings of $1 trillion (Exhibit 11). And because actual Medicare costs through 2014 came in well below 2013 projections, the CBO also recently revised downward its 10-year federal spending projection for 2015–2025.14 Spending for privately insured enrollees in marketplace plans also has slowed markedly, although growth rates per person have continued to exceed Medicare’s (Exhibit 12). This slower-than-expected growth has led the CBO in each of the past two years to lower its estimates of the federal cost of providing insurance subsidies. The slowdown has also benefited employers. Because of lower insurance cost growth in 2013 and 2014, the CBO in March 2015 revised its January 2015 10-year estimate of federal budget deficits downward by $431 billion. The agency explained that the revisions reflected increased revenues expected from taxable wage and salary growth—as employers spent less on health benefits and shifted a portion of employee compensation to salaries—as well as the decreased cost of federal marketplace subsidies.15 In August 2015, the CBO revised its 10-year deficit projection downward by another $200 billion, largely based on positive economic news.16 IMPACT OF PROVIDER PAYMENT REFORMS AND NEW INCENTIVES Analysis of the decline in health care spending growth indicates it has been driven partly by changes in the way health care is being delivered and paid for. Although it remains unclear how much of this phenomenon can be attributed to the Affordable Care Act, it seems clear that payment and delivery system changes set in motion by the ACA have made a significant contribution to lower cost growth as well as improvements in care. Among the ACA reforms that appear to be contributing to recent trends are: • A tightening of Medicare’s hospital “productivity adjustment,” which lowered the prices paid by the program. • Adjustments to Medicare’s annual updates of provider payment rates. • Lower payment rates for private Medicare Advantage plans. • Strong incentives to reduce hospital readmission rates and infections. • New payment methods for holding health care providers and systems more accountable for the quality and cost of care they provide. The ACA’s reforms targeting Medicare, including a tightening of payments to hospitals and lower excess payments to private plans participating in Medicare, have directly contributed to lower program spending. Other reforms created incentives for providers to redesign their care delivery systems. Providing evidence that tighter payment rates are not the only factor in Medicare’s lower rate of spending are the significant reductions in hospitalizations for conditions that can be treated with timely primary care and lower hospital readmisson rates. For Medicare beneficiaries, such “ambulatory care–sensitive” admissions have fallen 25 percent since 2010, continuing a decline that began prior to the ACA (Exhibit 13). Meanwhile, rates of hospital readmission within 30 days have fallen from more than 19 percent to 17 percent, after years of failing to improve.17 Tighter payments along with incentives have together contributed to the remarkable Medicare spending slowdown. Indeed, in 2012 and 2013, there was essentially no increase in spending per beneficiary (Exhibit 12). Early participants in a Medicare accountable care organization (ACO) program known as the Pioneer ACOs achieved $385 million savings for Medicare over the first two years (2012–13) relative to fee-for-servicebased medical groups, according to published analyses.18 To lower hospital readmissions for patients discharged to postacute care settings, incentives provided to ACOs, along with other targeted incentives, have led hospitals in communities around the country to select nursing homes that have a track record of lower infection rates and higher quality.19 Readmissions for medical conditions that could have been avoided with appropriate care drive up health costs and put elderly patients at risk.20 Emphasis on Primary Care Other ACA payment provisions create incentives to strengthen primary care, particularly for people with chronic illnesses and complex conditions.21 The goal is improved management of health conditions and complex prescription drug regimens, as well as prevention of complications that lead to hospital and nursing home stays. For example, Medicare and Medicaid, along with many private insurers, are promoting “patient-centered medical homes” and the use of care teams, with expanded roles for nurses and nurse aides. With these and other changes to medical care practice, the bulk of new jobs in health care delivery since 2010 has been in ambulatory care settings, not in hospitals—a reflection of longer-term shifts in care delivery22 as well as recent coverage and payment reforms (Exhibit 14). To the extent that physicians and hospitals continue to respond to the new incentives, potentially entire communities could benefit from the availability of more timely, more coordinated care and reduced acute care spending. Many state Medicaid programs are following suit and adopting similar payment and delivery system changes. With Medicaid and Medicare accounting for nearly 40 percent of total national health care spending and 43 percent of hospital spending, their policies have the potential to leverage further health system change across the country.23 Change in the Private Sector In the private sector, payers have embraced many of the same reforms the ACA has instituted in Medicare, including bundled or episode-based payments, ACOs, and enhanced payment for primary care medical homes. (The ACA, in fact, specifically encourages the private sector to join in Medicare’s payment initiatives.) Notably, private hospital use also has been in decline, a trend that has helped to moderate increases in health insurance costs.24 Indeed, studies show that reforms in the public and private health care markets have had positive spillover effects—in both directions.25,26 Also of note is the ACA’s “minimum loss ratio” requirement, which caps the portion of insurance premiums that can allocated for administrative costs and profits. The rule has yielded more than $5 billion in benefits to consumers from 2011 through 2013, either through the rebates paid by insurance companies or through reduced spending on overhead.27 In sum, the moderation in health costs growth through 2014 has benefited federal, state, and local governments, private employers, and workers and their families. Yet, as discussed later in this paper, the slowdown is unlikely to continue without further action to address the market forces that drive costs higher. POTENTIAL IMPACT OF LOWER COST GROWTH ON LABOR MARKETS AND WORKFORCE PRODUCTIVITY

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.