State governments can’t effectively redistribute – that’s the federal governments job
Seth Giertz and Mehmet Tosun December 2012. Seth Giertz: Associate Professor in the Department of Economics at the University of Nebraska Lincoln. Mehmet Tosun: Professor at the University of Nevada, Reno. “Migration elasticities, fiscal federalism, and the ability of states to redistribute income.” National Tax Journal https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1084&context=econfacpub
For several decades, the dominant view among economists was that the ability of state governments to redistribute income is limited, and thus redistribution should be left primarily to the federal government. This view was well articulated by Richard Musgrave (1971, p. 7): “Policies to adjust the distribution of income among individuals must be conducted on a nationwide basis … Regional measures are self-defeating, as the rich will leave and the poor will move to the more egalitarian-minded jurisdictions. Progressive income taxation at the upper as well as transfers at the lower end of the scale — if substantial in scope — must be uniform within the entire area over which there is a high degree of capital and labor mobility, which means they have to be a function of the national government” (Musgrave, 1971, p.7).