Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Every step of the DA is wrong – profits don’t go to R&D, most R&D isn’t actually innovative, most innovation occurs in non-profit centers, and innovation is useless if it’s ultra-expensive

Kesselheim et al 16 – Aaron S. Kesselheim, Associate Professor of Medicine at Harvard Medical School and a faculty member in the Division of Pharmacoepidemiology and Pharmacoeconomics in the Department of Medicine at Brigham and Women’s Hospital, M.D. and J.D. from University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine and Law School, MPH from Harvard School of Public Health, primary care physician at the Phyllis Jen Center for Primary Care at Brigham & Women’s Hospital, Jerry Avorn, Professor of Medicine at Harvard Medical School and Chief of the Division of Pharmacoepidemiology and Pharmacoeconomics in the Department of Medicine at Brigham and Women’s Hospital, M.D. from Harvard Medical School in 1974, and completed a residency in internal medicine at the Beth Israel Hospital in Boston, Ameet Sarpatwari, PhD in epidemiology at the University of Cambridge, Instructor in Medicine at Harvard Medical School, an Associate Epidemiologist at Brigham and Women’s Hospital, and Assistant Director of the Program On Regulation, Therapeutics, And Law (PORTAL) within the Division of Pharmacoepidemiology and Pharmacoeconomics, JD at the University of Maryland as a John L. Thomas Leadership Scholar, Principal Investigator on a Greenwall Foundation Making a Difference in Real-World Bioethics Dilemmas grant and a Faculty Affiliate with the Petrie-Flom Center for Health Law Policy, Biotechnology, and Bioethics at Harvard Law School and the Behavioral Insights Group at the Harvard Kennedy School (“The High Cost of Prescription Drugs in the United States: Origins and Prospects for Reform,” Journal of the American Medical Association, Vol. 316, No. 8, pgs. 858–871, August 23rd, Available to Subscribing Institutions)

Justifications for High Drug Prices The pharmaceutical industry has maintained that high drug prices reflect the research and development costs a company incurred to develop the drug, are necessary to pay for future research costs to develop new drugs, or both. It is true that industry often makes expensive investments in drug development and commercialization, particularly through late-stage clinical trials, which can be costly.84 These assertions have been used to justify high prices on the grounds that if drug prices are constrained, the pipeline of new medications will be adversely affected. Some economic analyses favored by the pharmaceutical industry contend that it costs $2.6 billion to develop a new drug that makes it to market.85 However, the rigor of this widely cited number has been disputed.86,87 A number of factors weigh against these rationales for high drug prices. First, important innovation that leads to new drug products is often performed in academic institutions and supported by investment from public sources such as the National Institutes of Health. A recent analysis of the most transformative drugs of the last 25 years found that more than half of the 26 products or product classes identified had their origins in publicly funded research in such nonprofit centers.88 Other analyses have highlighted the importance of small companies, many funded by venture capital.89,90 These biotech startups frequently take early-stage drug development research that may have its origins in academic laboratories and continue it until the product and the company can be acquired by a large manufacturer, as occurred with sofosbuvir. Arguments in defense of maintaining high drug prices to protect the strength of the drug industry misstate its vulnerability. The biotechnology and pharmaceutical sectors have for years been among the very best-performing sectors in the US economy. The proportion of revenue of large pharmaceutical companies that is invested in research and development is just 10% to 20% (Table 4); if only innovative product development is considered, that proportion is considerably lower.91 The contention that high prescription drug spending in the United States is required to spur domestic innovation has not been borne out in several analyses.92 A more relevant policy opportunity would be to address the stringency of congressional funding for the National Institutes of Health, such that its budget has barely kept up with inflation for most of the last decade. Given the evidence of the central role played by publicly funded research in generating discoveries that lead to new therapeutic approaches, this is one obvious area of potential intervention to address concerns about threats to innovation in drug discovery. Thus, there is little evidence of an association between research and development costs and drug prices93; rather, prescription drugs are priced in the United States primarily on the basis of what the market will bear. This explanation also helps to account for several high-profile case studies, including high-priced new branded products94 and exorbitantly priced generic drugs described above.95 In preparation for recent hearings on this topic, the US House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform subpoenaed internal correspondence from Turing and Valeant Pharmaceuticals, which had sharply increased the prices of older drugs the companies had acquired. The investigation revealed, for example, that Turing received “no pushback from payors” when it increased “Chenodal price 5x... [Thiola] price 21x... [and Daraprim] price 43x.”96 Similarly, Gilead spent $11 billion to purchase sofosbuvir from Pharmasset, a small biotechnology firm that developed the drug, based in part on federally funded research led by an investigator at Emory University.97 Gilead recouped almost all of this cost in the first year that sofosbuvir was on the market, recording sales of $10.3 billion in 2014.98 In December 2015, the US Senate Committee on Finance released a detailed report based on its access to internal company documents on Gilead’s strategies to maximize the prices it could charge for both that drug and its planned successor, which the company also owned.99 In the current system for drug payment in the United States, few options exist to counter this approach. Companies should of course be rewarded fairly for the research innovations they make that help generate new drug products and for their costly trial work that facilitates the assessment and availability of new medications. But providing them with large incentives to do the opposite is counterproductive. Clinical Consequences of High Drug Prices The high cost of prescription drugs in the United States has clinical as well as economic consequences.100,101 Even though more Americans have drug coverage as a result of the Medicare drug benefit plan and the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, cost-containment strategies in recent years have shifted an increasing share of drug expenses to patients.102 Private insurers have increased deductibles103 and most co-payments, and added a new payment tier for certain specialty drugs in which patients must pay coinsurance—often between 20% and 33% of the total drug price—rather than a simple co-payment.104 Although such cost-shifting measures have helped “bend the cost curve” for employers and payers, they can reduce use of effective medications.105,106 Almost a quarter of 648 respondents to a 2015 poll reported that they or another family member did not fill a prescription in the last year because of cost.107 In other studies, patients who were prescribed a costly branded product rather than a more affordable generic alternative were found to adhere to their regimen less well than those receiving a similar generic drug12 and to have worse health outcomes.108 Nonadherence due to all causes has been estimated to contribute to $105 billion in avoidable health care costs annually.109 In some cases, manufacturers have attempted to circumvent higher co-payments by providing patients with coupons that reimburse their out-of-pocket expenses.110 Coupons can be useful for patients with no other option, but they leave the insurer obliged to pay the much larger amount of each prescription’s costs, thereby increasing health care spending. This approach has become common for branded drugs that have comparable but much less expensive alternatives.111 Faced with fixed health care budgets, states with higher drug costs for their Medicaid programs have had to reduce other services or increase health care eligibility requirements.112 Several state Medicaid programs, for example, have imposed nonevidence-based policies to restrict sofosbuvir, including denying coverage to users of alcohol or other drugs.113,114

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.