Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Medicare for All is good for innovation

Anamaria Lopez, 7-8-2017, Anamaria Lopez is a research intern at INET. She is currently studying economics at Columbia University, where she works as a research assistant in the offices of Anya Schiffrin and Joseph Stiglitz. Specific areas of interest include economic policy and media freedom in Latin America and the Global South. "The Economic Case for Single Payer Health Care in the US", Institute for New Economic Thinking, https://www.ineteconomics.org/perspectives/blog/the-economic-case-for-single-payer-health-care-in-the-us, 6-28-2023, //ms

Why the government should be the payer L. Randall Wray, Professor of Economics at Bard College in New York, criticizes the framing of single-payer health care as “universal health insurance.” Wray argues that a single-payer health care system would in reality need to operate very differently than a universal health insurance program—largely because the concept of covering health care through an insurance system in the same way that we cover our homes or cars is fundamentally flawed. He explains that going to the doctor is not like going to the auto repair shop: Humans require consistent, preventative health care, and for-profit insurance isn’t designed to provide it. Wray notes that home or auto insurance is designed to be a “bad deal” for consumers, who pay premiums throughout their lives to protect themselves in the rare event that their house catches on fire or they get into a high-impact car crash. Health care is different because coverage isn’t just about catastrophe: Most costs go toward routine or preventative care, like annual checkups. As Wray puts it, routine health care is “not analogous to an ‘act of God’ that destroys your house: It is predictable, welcome, and life-enhancing.” Economist Gerald Friedman, also of University of Massachusetts Amherst, has similar concerns about applying insurance companies’ profit-based business model to health care coverage. Such an arrangement leads to “adverse selection,” he says. Friedman explains that because of the concentration of health care spending on a few sick and injured individuals, private insurers will seek to save costs by identifying and avoiding such people— a practice called “lemon dropping”—while attracting the healthy—or “cherry picking.” Even with Obamacare protections around preexisting conditions, insurers are able to drop out of the Obamacare market altogether. While these strategies are profitable for insurers, they raise costs for consumers, putting those who can least afford to pay at risk. Like Baker, Friedman is also concerned with the soaring price of pharmaceuticals and hospital services in the U.S., and argues that only a single-payer system can reverse the trend: A system with multiple insurers leaves none with the market power to stand up to elite providers, including drug companies and hospitals. Gerald Friedman Over time, Friedman argues, a single-payer system will not only cut costs, but also significantly improve the quality of health care and lead to more innovation and deeper research. For example, there are currently no data on outcomes and health care utilization across the country other than those collected by the VA and Medicare. The mass of data a single-payer system would accumulate—across the population and over time—would open doors to more conclusive research and “allow for quality analysis of treatment and provider behavior,” says Friedman. In the long run, he says, such data—and the system that produces it—could revolutionize the way health care is practiced in the US.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.