Implementing renewables greatly increases retail energy costs-- the best studies prove
Brian Murray, 6-17-2019, Brian Murray is the Director of the Duke University Energy Initiative, a university-wide interdisciplinary hub for energy research, education and engagement, and research professor at Duke’s Nicholas School of the Environment, where he teachs courses in economics and energy systems transformation."The Paradox of Declining Renewable Costs and Rising Electricity Prices," Forbes, https://www.forbes.com/sites/brianmurray1/2019/06/17/the-paradox-of-declining-renewable-costs-and-rising-electricity-prices/?sh=253a1e061d5b//Jmorg
Most energy observers recognize that the cost of renewable energy has declined dramatically in the last decade. The investment firm Lazard produces a periodic report on the average cost of generation from different electric power sources – the “levelized cost of electricity” in energy geek parlance. shows that over the last decade the levelized cost per unit of electricity from new utility-scale onshore wind and photovoltaic (PV) solar power plants has dropped about 70 and 90 percent, respectively. In many places, the cost of new renewable generation is at or below that of existing conventional sources like natural gas, coal and nuclear.This would seem to be good news for those interested in making energy clean and cheap. Yet, a recent study suggests that policies that mandate renewable use have driven up the retail price of electricity and have been an expensive way to achieve greenhouse gas reductions – often an implicit reason for those mandates. While it seems paradoxical that electricity prices could be rising while generation costs are falling, this possibility is an artifact of how electricity markets work and how these workings have grown more complex as the industry evolves from a more centralized fossil fuel-based generation base to a more distributed and renewable base. Let’s explore this and see what it says about the road ahead.Why Renewable Generation Costs Have PlummetedThere are several reasons for the steep reduction in renewable costs. One is the improvement in basic product design. Wind turbines are than a decade ago. Although the new designs are more expensive up front, increased capacity and capacity utilization have outpaced those higher costs to lower the cost of energy produced. A typical base-to-blade tip height for onshore turbines is now often over 500 feet – as tall as the Washington Monument – and we are seeing single turbine capacity of 5 MW or more, enough to power around 1,700 US homes over the course of a year.Another reason for the cost decline is improvement in manufacturing efficiency which has lowered the costs of producing solar PV panels dramatically, particularly in China. And per unit installation “soft” costs are declining as project developers gain more experience and installations have moved from small scale (rooftop solar) to utility-scale operations (solar farms of hundreds of acres).These dramatic renewable generation cost declines have been attributed to policies such as tax credits, preferential feed-in tariffs, and renewable portfolio standards (RPS), which directly target the use of renewables, expand demand and create cost-reducing economies of scale to meet that demand. Renewables that were once inarguably much more expensive and required large subsidies and mandates to incentivize adoption have slid into grid parity territory, now able to compete directly with conventional sources in many places.How Electricity Prices Can Rise While Generation Costs FallThe release this spring of a by economists at the Energy Policy Institute at University of Chicago (EPIC) ignited a debate on the cost-effectiveness of renewable mandates. The paper examined the effects of renewable portfolio standards (RPS) programs, which have been adopted by 29 states and Washington DC, finding that these policies have raised retail prices considerably and have reduced CO2 emissions only modestly.We will return to that debate in a moment, but for now let’s ask - if the cost of renewable power generation is falling, how can their use cause retail prices to rise?This paradox is even more striking when we consider that more renewables actually can drive down the wholesale prices that electricity generators are paid. Because variable renewable energy (VRE) resources wind and solar incur virtually all of their costs up front and incur no fuel costs to produce electricity, the average cost of VRE generation is much higher than the marginal cost, which is close to zero. Much electricity in the US is transacted in states with competitive wholesale electricity markets. Marginal costs set prices in competitive markets, which means that the penetration of VRE can push down wholesale power prices, even more so when the VRE resource is receiving a per unit subsidy, as is the case with wind. This is something that has placed such as coal, nuclear and natural gas plants that do incur fuel costs and other marginal costs of generation. It would seem, then, that higher renewables should lead to lower electricity prices.But wholesale prices are paid to the generators; the retail prices paid by final customers reflect the full cost of delivering electricity. Generation, though the largest component, only accounts for of the total cost. The other main costs affected by renewables integration are transmission and distribution of electricity to its point of use, reliability costs to maintain stable voltage and frequency, maintenance needed to keep the system running, depreciation and taxes.Unit costs, however, tell only part of the story. Individual power generators, whether conventional power plants or wind farms, seldom operate in isolation; they are each part of a larger grid-connected system that aggregates power across generators to deliver power to a region of consumers. VRE’s effect on system costs will depend in part on the cost of the electricity that it is displacing, which in turn depends on the location and timing of its deployment. Wind generation at night in the Midwest may be displacing coal, while solar generation in the afternoon in California may be displacing natural gas, each with different cost profiles. And to handle the intermittency of VRE, system operators need to activate ramping resources more frequently to meet demand. These flexible plants are typically more expensive to operate and thus higher deployment can raise total system costs even as renewable costs decline. Moreover, these resources must be kept on hand to provide reliable capacity in a market characterized by more intermittent supply and the costs of maintaining this capacity is passed along to consumers.To cost-effectively scale up renewables, they must be sited where they are most productive – in places with plenty of sun, wind and land. That is typically not close to the population centers where users locate, so more transmission infrastructure is required to connect supply and demand. This may be having an effect on system costs. Between 2012 and 2017, when , . While not all transmission cost increases nationally can be attributed to renewables expansion – maintaining old lines and modernizing for grid reliability are other reasons – there are notable cases where renewables are driving transmission investments. The project in Texas, for example, invested $7 billion to connect wind generation in sparsely populated west Texas to the state’s population centers.The connection between generation costs and retail prices is also affected by whether the state in question has traditional cost-of-service regulation or has restructured to allow wholesale or retail competition. The former situation may create more room for passing along to rate payers the recovery costs of stranded non-renewable assets resulting from RPS mandates.The EPIC paper mentioned above took many of these factors into consideration and used econometrics to conclude that states with an RPS had statistically significant higher post-implementation prices than those without. Some critics argued against used, the extent to which it was peer-reviewed, and drawn for the wider policy debate. Criticism is standard fare in academic research, especially when a critical and high profile policy is at issue. I don’t intend here to divine the criticisms and render a verdict on the study’s validity. Rather, if we were to take their findings at face value that RPS mandates drive up retail prices, what does that foretell about future efforts to scale up renewables?