Ripple effects
Russell Tucker 14, Director, Strategic Analysis & Chief Economist at the National Rural Electric Cooperative Association, Zach Schloss, Michael Leitman, Dave Olivier, "Affordable Electricity and Economic Development: The Role of Electric Cooperatives in the 21st Century", www.nreca.coop/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/Final_NRECA_Affordable_Electricity_White_Paper.pdf
This study first illustrated the effects of increased electricity consumption (“pure work”) on U.S. economic growth. It then highlighted the impact of affordable electricity on economic productivity and the “useful work” done via U.S. electricity consumption. In its entirety, then, this study has identified a causal relationship running from affordable electricity to U.S. economic growth (see Figure 6). More specifically, as electricity prices rise and the implementation of cost-effective electricity-using technologies slows, the “useful work” done via electricity consumption falls, in turn suppressing economic growth. Conversely, as electricity prices fall and the adoption of cost-effective electricity-using technologies grows, electricity consumption rises, leading to more “useful work” and economic growth. While some scholars have observed a “decoupling” of the growth of electricity use and GDP in recent years (see de Bruyn & Opschoor, 1997; Smith, 2014; Spross, 2014; The World Bank, 1992), affordable electricity use remains a strong indicator of economic performance (see Figure 7) and has, if anything, become increasingly vital as the U.S. economy has come to rely more on digital technologies. As energy policy analyst Pierre-Olivier Pineau (2002) notes, electricity is not only “one of the building blocks” of modern economies, but it “has also been at the root of all productivity improvements in developed countries and it now fuels the ‘new digital economy’” (p. 999). This study reinforces the findings of much research that has continued to find a link between affordable electricity and the U.S. economy. Using U.S. data from 35 U.S. industrial segments since 1958, for example, Jorgenson has found that “in virtually all sectors of the U.S. economy, technical progress is total energy using,” meaning that decreases in the affordability of energy types like electricity decrease productivity growth in those industries and ultimately impede economic growth (Berndt, 1990). Writing with regard to the U.S., the World Economic Forum (2012) echoed these findings, explaining that because “electricity is an input for nearly all goods and services in the economy, an increase in electricity prices would be felt throughout the economy” (p. 18). All else being equal, if electricity prices were to rise or technological innovation were to be limited to the point that electricity became “unaffordable,” the ensuing decline in electricity consumption would abate economic progress by diminishing the effectiveness of labor, increasing unemployment, hindering industrial productivity, decreasing consumer spending on other goods and services, and limiting technological progress. In this sense, productivity and economic growth cannot be sustained without affordable electricity.