underemployment is core concern of FJG
Pavlina R. Tcherneva, April 2018, “The Job Guarantee: Design, Jobs, and Implementation,” Levy Economics Institute, https://www.levyinstitute.org/pubs/wp_902.pdf, accessed 5/25/23, mw
For the purposes of this paper full employment is defined as a situation where any person of
legal working age who wants to work is able to obtain employment at a living wage and decent
working conditions. This includes but is not limited to new entrants in the labor market, people
in “hidden unemployment” who are not normally counted in the official statistics, and
individuals who are employed involuntarily in part-time working arrangements or other forms
of precarious work.
At the macroeconomic level, unemployment is understood as:
A monetary problem: It is a consequence of business cycles dynamics and profitseeking firms behavior, as well as the State’s inadequate management of the currency
and the monetary system.
A situation that cannot be remedied by private firms: The private sector is unable to
produce and maintain tight full employment over the long run.
A problem that is best understood as a silent epidemic: There is a distinct and
discernable geographical pattern and propagation mechanism of unemployment, which
mimics the behavior of a virus or mass contagion (Tcherneva 2017). Joblessness behaves
like a disease and generates large social, health, and economic costs.
A problem that is already “paid for”: The costs of these social and economic ills—
both in real and financial terms—are already “paid for” by the economy and society at
large.
A problem by design and a public sector failure: Unemployment is a problem created
by concrete policy measures (targeting a non-accelerating rate of unemployment
[NAIRU], austerity policies). The government has chosen an explicit policy of keeping a
percentage of the population in involuntary unemployment (the NAIRU is a policy
benchmark). The government is also responsible for supporting the unemployed, i.e., the
unemployed are already in the public sector. Government, public institutions, and civil
society are not only paying the direct cost of unemployment, but more importantly are
already bearing the large associated real costs of unemployment.
A moral failure: Unemployment has been used as the main bulwark against inflation
and economic instability and is considered a “necessary evil.” The idea that some people
will necessarily lose their jobs and livelihoods in the fight against other economic ills is
a profound moral failure of the economics profession.
Unemployment is the failure and responsibility of the public sector and it is already “paid for.”
By contrast, the JG offers a superior policy option to the current approach, and one that is
macroeconomically sound and humane. It pays to employ the unemployed, preventing and
reducing the outsized costs of unemployment, supporting the production of valuable public
goods, and investing in and empowering people, planet, and community.