Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Wall street taxes (aka financial transaction taxes) reduce economic investment and suck

Boesen 1-11-2021. ( Ulrik Boesen, senior policy analyst at the Center for State Tax Policy at the Tax Foundation, "The Drawbacks of State Taxes on Financial Transactions." Tax Foundation. Web. 1-11-2021. accessed 7-3-2023. < https://taxfoundation.org/state-tax-financial-transactions/ >. JBFunke)

Historical examples both in the U.S. and abroad suggest that lawmakers should be careful when designing taxes for the financial market. A well-functioning financial market provides a key service for businesses and entrepreneurs in need of capital or risk management. In addition, it provides savers with a chance to get a better return than they would get with a standard savings account—especially with interest levels near zero.Nonetheless, imposing an FTT to raise revenue has been, and is being, discussed by lawmakers at both the federal and state levels. During the Democratic Party’s presidential primary contest in 2020, a few candidates supported FTTs at the federal level.[3] At the state level, lawmakers in New York and New Jersey are discussing levying such taxes.[4] There is also federal opposition to FTTs. In October 2020, Representatives Patrick T. McHenry (R-NC) and Bill Huizenga (R-MI) introduced the Protecting Retirement Savers and Everyday Investors Act, which would prohibit states from imposing FTTs that could affect residents of other states.[5]Transaction taxes more generally are quite common at the state level. Many states impose a version of a transaction tax known as the real property transfer tax, which is commonly a low-rate levy on the transfer of real property.The issues with levying a tax on financial transactions are related to the nature of the financial markets. First, financial transactions are a flawed tax base as the tax is levied every time a security is transferred, resulting in tax “pyramiding” similar to the effect of a gross receipts tax. “Pyramiding” refers to a tax that is levied on the same economic activity many times over—in this case, each time a share is traded. Second, an FTT would raise transaction costs, which would result in a lower trading volume and lower liquidity as even low rates could be punitive, especially for low-margin high frequency trading (HFT).[6] Low liquidity (or quoted depth) makes it more difficult for traders to buy and sell shares at the best price level. Third, taxing trades might result in investors holding on to the securities to avoid the tax, regardless of whether they should actually be holding on to them.[7] Disincentivizing trading is not ideal as economists generally think of trades as highly valuable activity that benefits both parties. Fourth, an FTT would result in income being taxed multiple times. FTTs tax the act of trading itself, on top of existing capital gains, personal income, and corporate income taxes.States can limit the adverse effects of an FTT by making certain design choices but are unlikely to avoid them completely. They must consider a number of tax policy trade-offs related to this design. Choice of tax base will impact market participant behavior and choice of rate will impact market volume and liquidity. This paper discusses those trade-offs and presents arguments against an FTT as both a revenue tool and deterrent of “undesired” trading.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.