Plan destroys Congressional focus on foreign policy while wrecking state experimentation---CP alone solves
Riedl 17 [Brian Riedl is a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute, bachelor's degree in economics and political science from the University of Wisconsin and a master's degree in public affairs from Princeton University, 4-12-2017 https://www.usnews.com/opinion/articles/2017-04-12/washington-is-a-problem-let-the-states-have-more-power]
Devolution recognizes that there is little reason for Washington to impose one-size-fits-all policies on all 50 states and 3,144 counties and county equivalents. Blue states should be free to build larger governments with higher taxes – and red states should be free to do the opposite. Governments can customize local programs to local needs, with solutions based on local values. And citizens can vote with their feet.
Devolution also promotes experimentation. The collapsing ObamaCare exchanges show that even the smartest experts can get the policy terribly wrong. Rather than subject about 320 million people to Washington's mistakes (and then deadlock on a fix), it is better to empower all 50 states to experiment with their own unique policy approaches. Over time, successful policies will be copied by other states, while failures can be replaced with minimal damage.
History supports state experimentation. Many of the early-20th century progressive reforms were road-tested by governors like Robert LaFollette of Wisconsin. More recently, bold policies pursued by former Wisconsin Gov. Tommy Thompson inspired the successful, bipartisan 1996 welfare reforms. On the flip side, state pension bankruptcies as well as Vermont's recent enactment and abandonment of a single-payer health care plan provide valuable lessons on policies to avoid.
Devolution also helps Congress focus on key national functions such as national security, foreign policy, immigration and economic growth, rather than be bogged down on issues like where to build a highway in Phoenix or what health programs are best for Akron. Better that Congress perform a few functions well instead of many functions badly.