Russia will retaliate – Bad economy is a threat to Putin’s rule
Ash ‘22 – (Timothy, Professional economist for 30 years and a soverign strategist at Bluebay Asset Management in London, “Will an EU oil price cap limit Russian aggression?” Chatham House, December 5, 2022, https://www.chathamhouse.org/2022/12/will-eu-oil-price-cap-limit-russian-aggression)//DDD
Russia has threatened to retaliate by stopping oil sales to any countries participating in the oil price cap. This is likely a bluff as Russia’s own export volumes and total revenues would be hit at a time when foreign exchange reserves have been under sharp downward pressure – falling by more than $100 billion per year to date despite a rising current account surplus.
There are also technical issues for Russia in halting the supply of oil as its storage capacity is finite. Similarly, stopping production at oil wells could cause long-term damage to the country’s production potential.
The West’s struggle to agree an oil price cap underlines the difficulties more generally in applying sanctions to countries such as Russia which play a role in the global supply chain (oil and energy in this case). The objective of sanctions is always to damage the target more than the countries applying the sanctions and there is also a political imperative to maintain sanctions unity.
The latter has tended to take priority, resulting in sanctions of the lowest common denominator, moderating both the severity and effectiveness of sanctions as they have been applied to Russia.
But as ever with sanctions, it is important to view them as just one part of a broader coercive Western response to Russia which can include other diplomatic sanctions, military options, and cyber. Sanctions are not a silver bullet, they are meant to change Russian calculus to encourage a change in behaviour.
Limiting Russia’s ability to use its ‘energy card’
One particularly important point when it comes to oil, energy, and commodity markets has been how market forces have mitigated Russia’s own efforts to use the energy card against the West, particularly against Europe.
As Russia has cut gas supplies to Europe – and as gas and energy prices have rocketed – demand, particularly for gas, has adjusted to be significantly lower – 25-30 per cent lower in Germany for example – and global growth has crimped which has finally begun to weigh down on global energy prices.
A global recession brought on by the crisis in Ukraine, and Russia’s offensive action to limit energy supplies to Europe, could ultimately prove to be the straw that breaks the camel’s back, by resulting in significant reduced demand for Russian energy.
With Russia’s economy weighed down by the costs of war and sanctions, a collapse in total energy import revenues could prove to be fatal to the Putin regime over the medium term.
The West’s efforts to cap Russian oil prices has been met with irritation among other energy producers, particularly in the Gulf, ridiculing what they say are attempts to distort the market. The irony seems to have been lost on these very same OPEC members whose raison d’etre is market manipulation in their favour.
But perhaps the reaction of these states simply reflects a fear that the West’s efforts to coordinate the actions of energy consumers could morph into something which eventually undermines the dominant position of OPEC itself in the global oil market.