Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

3) Decentralization DA: The affs centralization of resources is one that solidifies the economic institutions in place and coopts the project of Buddhist economics—link turns fail because of federal involvement

Bhusal 18, Indra Prasad Bhusal is Assistant Campus Chief of New Horizon College Butwal., “Fiscal decentralization in Buddhist economics: An interactive analysis from Lumbini”, Research Nepal Journal of Development Studies (RNJDS), October 5, 2018, https://doi.org/10.3126/rnjds.v1i1.21272 ,$$G

At the beginning Buddhist perspective on the subject of economics was simple, a theological issue of Buddha’s ideology. While not seeking to present a completely comprehensive Buddhist economic theory, he provides many tools for reflection, ways of looking at economic question based on a considered appreciation of the way things are, the way we are. The hope that by making this work available in English it may go at least a short way towards resolving what has been called the current 'impasse of economics', and to awaken readers to the wide-reaching contemporary relevance of the timeless truths that the Buddha discovered and shared with us (Payutto, 2016).

“The federal system was created with the intention of combining the different advantages which result from the magnitude and the littleness of nations”. The quotes of Alexis de Tocqueville, Democracy in America has given the base of theory decentralization. The research will be guided by this Toqueville ideology of Fiscal decentralization.

When regional and local governments are involved in financing their own expenditures, at least at the margin, they will be more accountable to their citizens (and the central government) for the efficient delivery of public services. In contrast, when the bulk of financing of local services comes from revenues transferred from a higher level of government, local governments are less likely to be parsimonious with those expenditures. Thus, tax sharing formulas need to be constructed in a fashion that encourages (or at least not discourages) local governments from developing their own-source revenues (Kee, 2003). In recent years, there have been multiple extensions of the traditional theory of fiscal federalism (or the organization of intergovernmental fiscal relations) first developed by Oates in 1972. Viewing government as a benevolent agent, it has created a decentralization theorem, which states that in the presence of diverse preferences and needs, provision of services from a decentralized government will lead to increased citizen welfare. This occurs because decentralized government leads to information advantages and more flexibility in adapting to citizens’ needs and preferences, as emphasized earlier (Martinez-Vazquez, 2011)

Analysis/Discussion The Decentralization Development from Peace: For a public good–the consumption of which is defined over geographical subsets of the total population, and for which the costs of providing each level of output of the good in each jurisdiction are the same for the central or for the respective local government–it will always be more efficient (or at least as efficient) for local governments to provide the Pareto-efficient levels of output for their respective jurisdictions than for the central government to provide any specified and uniform level of output across all jurisdictions (Oates, 2006). “The keynote of Buddhist Economics, therefore, is simplicity and non-violence. From an economist’s point of view, the marvel of the Buddhist way of life is the utter rationality of its pattern – amazingly small means leading to extra-ordinary satisfactory results” - E. F. Schumacher, Small is Beautiful (Kekendure, 2010) For at least another hundred years, we must pretend to ourselves and to everyone that fair is foul and foul is fair: for foul is useful and fair is not. Avarice, usury, and precaution must be gods for a little longer still. For many they can lead us out of the tunnel of economic necessity into daylight.” (Economic possibilities for our grandchildren.) - John Maynard Keynes (Kekendure, 2010) “Men make their own history, but they do not make it just as they please; they do not make it under circumstances chosen by themselves, but under circumstances directly encountered, given, and transmitted from the past.” - Karl Marx (Kekendure, 2010)

As Nepal is a country of Gautam Buddha, Nepal's every policy is almost guided by the Buddhists Philosophy. Since early 1960, Nepal adopted Decentralization as a process to mobilize people's participation in development. This has undergone significant changes over time. Historically, the development process of Decentralization could be categorized into two important phases: Phase I (1960-1990) and Phase II (1990 to date). Phase I may be treated as transition phase. In 1962 the Decentralization Policy was framed. This was the first officially prepared policy framework on Decentralization. Some other features of this phase are the promulgation of Decentralization Act 1982 and Decentralization Regulation 1984 (Ligal, Shrestha, Chapagain, Bista, & Maharjan, 2005).

Phase II may be considered as the consolidation and carry-forward phase in the development of Decentralization policies in the country. The Constitution of Nepal 1991 has incorporated Decentralization into its directive of the state policy and is stated as "Decentralization should be the means for ensuring optimum participation of people in governance and hence enjoy the benefit of democracy". The promulgation of three separate local governments Acts (DDC, Municipality and VDC) in March 1992 was the beginning of a systematic process to Decentralization in the country. Limitations in these acts resulted subsequently in bringing out another unified act namely, Local Self Governance Act (LSGA) in 1999 (Ligal, Shrestha, Chapagain, Bista, & Maharjan, 2005). The enactment of LSGR and LBFAR clarifies the roles and responsibilities of each level of LBs together with the types of resources they command. A system of inter-government transfer was practiced to support LBs in carrying out their function including much needed developmental activities in their jurisdiction. The importance of decentralized local governance was increasingly recognized during this phase. Post 1990s period may, therefore, be considered as the landmark in the development of Decentralization process in the country (Ligal, Shrestha, Chapagain, Bista, & Maharjan, 2005).

Poverty Reduction through Decentralization: As a step towards accelerating the process of Decentralization, in fiscal year 2001/02, some key services, such as, primary education, primary health care, agriculture and livestock extension services were devolved and the responsibility of managing and delivering of these services were handed over to the LBs and the local management committees. Center fully backed up these services along with resource requirements. In line with the commitment towards Decentralization, the Tenth Plan (2002-2007), clearly stated Decentralization as one of its strategies for poverty reduction and as such, aims to achieve the objective of poverty reduction by enabling the local people through their participation in the decision-making and governance process (Ligal, Shrestha, Chapagain, Bista, & Maharjan, 2005). The Tenth plan continued the process of devolution further by devolving services of higher level, such as; health posts and primary health center in the case of 3 primary health services and lower secondary and secondary school in the case of education have also been gradually devolved. Following the recommendations made in the study on Expenditure Assignment commissioned by LBFC and DASU/DANIDA HMG/N had devolved infrastructure sector involving rural roads, small irrigation and small drinking water projects to DDCs from the fiscal year 2004/05. More recently, HMG/N had announced its plan to go on full-scale devolution in 14 districts, one each from 14 zones from the fiscal year 2005/06 (Ligal, Shrestha, Chapagain, Bista, & Maharjan, 2005). So decentralization from Buddhists perspective is based on the philosophy of small is beautiful.

Empiricism in Buddhist's philosophy of Decentralization: The term empirical was originally used to refer to certain ancient Greek practitioners of medicine who rejected adherence to the dogmatic doctrines of the day, preferring instead to rely on the observation of phenomena as perceived in experience. Later empiricism referred to a theory of knowledge in philosophy which adheres to the principle that knowledge arises from experience and evidence gathered specifically using the senses. In scientific use, the term empirical refers to the gathering of data using only evidence that is observable by the senses or in some cases using calibrated scientific instruments. What early philosophers described as empiricist and empirical research have in common is the dependence on observable data to formulate and test theories and come to conclusions.

Fiscal decentralization refers to the process of granting autonomy to the local self-government to mobilize financial resources which shows how much central government cedes fiscal impact to sub-national governments. It is a bottom up planning approach with the aim of converging the people's participation. Nepal is rich in diverse resources. Considering the eminent role to be played by local institution to mobilize these resources, Nepal has adopted the principle of decentralization since 1960 and various acts and laws were enacted since then to strengthen the efforts. According to the present Local-Self Governance Act (LSGA)-1999, local resources consisting of the grants provided by the central government (matching and non-matching grant), local revenue (tax and non-tax) and loan (internal and external) could have been implemented by the respective local bodies (Shrestha, 2005). Lord Buddha was born as Prince Siddhartha Gautama of the Shakya Kingdom in the gardens of Lumbini in 623 BC. His journey in this world began in the gardens of Lumbini when his mother Queen Mayadevi was travelling from Tilaurakot, the capital of the Shakya Kingdom, to her family home in Devdaha to give birth. It was here that the newborn infant took his first seven steps toward the East beginning a path to enlightenment which would change humankind.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.