Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

15-minute cities further marginalize impoverished communities.

Feargus O'Sullivan 21, Feargus O'Sullivan is a writer for CityLab in London, focused on European infrastructure, design and urban governance, “Where the ‘15-Minute City’ Falls Short”, 3-2-2021, https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-03-02/the-downsides-of-a-15-minute-city//KOO

The idea of a “15-minute city,” in which residents live within a short walk or bike ride of all their daily needs has been embraced by many mayors around the world during the global pandemic as a central planning tenet.

But there are dangers of applying a model conceived in Europe to many North American cities, some urban experts warn. Transplanting the 15-minute city template across the Atlantic could be “presumptive and colonial” said Toronto-based urban designer and thinker Jay Pitter at the CityLab 2021 conference, hosted by Bloomberg Philanthropies and the Aspen Institute.

“I'm a champion of the hyper-local, as certainly we need more resilient, climate change-resistant cities.” said Pitter, who works on public space designs in a number of U.S. cities. “However, I am averse to this concept. It doesn't take into account the histories of urban inequity, intentionally imposed by technocratic and colonial planning approaches, such as segregated neighborhoods, deep amenity inequity and discriminatory policing of our public spaces.”

The core principles behind the 15-minute city aren’t new to urban planning. They derive from an old history of designing cities around people rather than cars, and many European cities that were planned before the invention of the automobile are better suited to this notion. But the idea that has been popularized during the pandemic is that all cities — including European ones — must center future planning on the goal of ensuring car-free access to basic necessities, such as health care, schools, employment and food. It’s a lofty goal, but one that is unlikely to reach all neighborhoods in many cities without drastic interventions and investments. Pitter warns that simply injecting design changes such as bike lanes and parklets into a neighborhood will not reverse segregation that has been embedded into city planning.

“We've actually designed cities to create buffers between us across race and class specifically, and this proposal completely ignores a century of planning interventions that have actually concretized deep social divisions between people.”

Ignoring and failing to tackle that could serve to further alienate marginalized communities, Pitter added.

“What we see already within marginalized communities is resistance to things that are actually really wonderful and beneficial, like more walkability or bike lanes. The reason we see this resistance is because these kinds of approaches, while good for us and the environment, also often spur gentrification. And so communities are very nervous about that.”

Speaking at the same session, Dan Hill, strategic director of Vinnova, Sweden’s national innovation agency, agreed with Pitter’s critique. But he borrowed a suggestion from his own organization’s current project for helping to overcome these concerns: Sweden is has a new initiative piloted by Vinnova — which Hill styles as focusing on the “one-minute city” directly outside people’s front doors — that hopes to empower residents to make their own decisions about what happens on their own street.

Any hyper-local planning strategy must start first with this kind of profound community engagement, he said.

“If the 15-minute city is seen a sort of a top-down technocratic, urban planning, then clearly that could...exacerbate things,” Hill said. But this outcome could be avoided, Hill said, with a more “systematic and holistic approach” that has “social relationships as the starting point, so that[hyper-local planning] becomes the vehicle through which you can address questions of social or environmental justice.”

He added that an ambitious goal such as the 15-minute city requires cities to abandon traditional notions of urban planning as divorced from other local policies.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.