MPA’s are weak---can’t spill over to solve much larger alt causes like climate and oil spills
Gies 18 [Erica Gies covers water, energy, critters and more on the science and environment beat, holds a master’s degree in literature, with a focus in eco-criticism, her work has appeared in The New York Times, Scientific American, Nature, The Economist and others, this story originally appeared in bioGraphic, an online magazine about nature and sustainability powered by the California Academy of Sciences, “Does Size Matter? Debating the Role of Marine Protected Areas,” https://deeply.thenewhumanitarian.org/oceans/articles/2018/04/27/does-size-matter-debating-the-role-of-marine-protected-areas]
Whether we manage to set aside 2 percent of our oceans, or 10 percent or even 16 percent, scientists and policymakers are fiddling around the edges of decline. And because the science is complex and there aren’t simple answers, and because the need is vast and the money and political will are slim, conservationists are fighting over scraps. They are recommending compromises that embed loss into the calculation. If we really want to maintain biodiversity and ensure a healthy future for our oceans that sustain human life – with food, CO2 absorption, climate regulation and much more – according to the International Union for Conservation of Nature, we need to protect 30 percent of our oceans with no extractive activities by 2030. Some scientists have suggested that an even higher percentage is necessary for long-term sustainability.
And even the strongest MPAs cannot protect against climate change, oil spills, plastic pollution, agricultural runoff, illegal fishing – all factors aggravated by the twin fundamental drivers of biodiversity loss: the exponentially increasing number of humans on the planet and their consumption of resources, according to a recent paper in Nature Ecology & Evolution. But protected areas can provide space for resilience.
To make the best possible decisions that will give the greatest number of species a shot, marine scientists are calling for more investment in monitoring and a reporting framework linked to conservation goals so that the limited resources the world is willing to set aside for other species will buy maximum value. MPAs need to be placed “where they can make the most difference,” says Barnes.