Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Research and innovation can create unanticipated harmful effects which may outweigh any benefits.

Coad, et al 21

[Alex Coad has a PhD from Université Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne and the Sant'Anna School. He is a Professor at Waseda Business School. Paul Nightingale received his Doctor of Philosophy at the University of Sussex and is the Director of the Science Policy Research Unit at the University of Sussex. Jack Stilgoe is a Professor of Science and Technology Policy at University College London. Antonio Vezzani has a PhD in Economics from University of Rome Tor Vergata. He is a Professor in Economics at Roma Tre University. “Editorial: the dark side of innovation,” .] cgarland

2.1. Issues of scale: explorations by lead users vs the dependence of mass consumers Small problems due to one-off explorations are generally accepted to be benign and acceptable. For example, small scale pollution from a pioneering scientific experiment is probably acceptable to most people. But if this scales up through the everyday habits of millions of consumers worldwide, harmful effects can accumulate and interact, and new problems can appear. The example of congestion and pollution is a classical case used by economists to illustrate that (public) goods have a capacity beyond which interference (or cumulative) effects become noticeable to then increase disproportionally (Rothenberg 1970). Similar effects apply in many other circumstances and political decisions about the impact of a technology may mistakenly be made by focusing on the initial circumstances, rather than the problems that emerge when the technology diffuses and is used at scale. In this vein, the adoption of new products and technologies can cause problems due to rising demand for key inputs, like the rapid growth in the demand for cobalt (a key input for lithium-ion batteries) causing social problems such as corruption, environmental pollution, extreme poverty and child labour (Conca 2020). 2.2. End-of-product-life considerations Another dark side of innovation relates to end-of-product-life considerations, that are predictable from the start, but often ignored until the end. Examples include the disposal of nuclear waste, mining clean-up operations, and heavy metal leakage from the recycling of electronic waste. With new technologies, and especially technologies with long work- ing lives, these end of life costs may be uncertain. In some instances, a new technology can reduce these costs, but in many others rising social expectations and more stringent environmental and health regulations can substantially increase costs over time. Recycling can reduce the environmental impact of waste. However, if new materials such as plastics are relatively cheap, recycling can be prohibitively expensive compared to landfill or burning. In one example, from the UK, Westminster council sent 82% of all household waste – including that put in recycling bins – for incineration in 2017/18 (Franklin-Wallis 2019). Disposal problems are exacerbated in the case of planned obsolescence, where products have deliberately shortened lifetimes, or are designed such that they are impossible or difficult to repair.1 For example, Apple has been repeatedly accused of deliberately slowing its iPhones in order to increase the sales of new products, and restricts the repair of Apple products even in the case of fairly simple repairs (Svensson et al. 2018). Despite the usual focus on the benefits of renewable energy, Hansen and Nygaard (this issue) provide evidence on the dangers. New technologies for solar panels cause problems of heavy metal disposal, in particular for lead, which is a potent neurotoxin. Many Sub- Saharan African nations lack capabilities to dispose of waste, and there are uncertainties about the longer-term environmental performance of solar panels. The recycling of hazardous materials is often done by the poor who lack equipment, protection, and political representation. Innovations that address one kind of pollution can create new problems, that fall on different people, and these costs should not be ignored, even if the overall improvement is substantial. 2.3. Features vs bugs: ‘unintended’ versus ‘unanticipated’ consequences Innovations can be intentionally harmful, such as for example the atomic bomb, auto- matic rifles, electric chairs, or the ‘Spanish donkey.’ These innovations clearly cause great harm by creating new opportunities for individuals to more effectively carry out harmful intentions. More in general, the introduction of new technology can lead to ‘revenge effects.’ Pesticide and antibiotic use can create conditions where new super-weeds and super- bugs evolve, air-conditioning increases external temperatures, and expanding roads can increase traffic and lead to more congestion. Tenner (1997) sub-divides these revenge effects into rearranging, repeating, recomplicating, regenerating and recongesting effects. In some cases, the harm from innovation comes not from regular use but from unanticipated accidents, such as Chernobyl. In other cases, the harm is an unintended yet anticipated outcome that comes from proper use. This harm can be well-known or hidden. A known side-effect of the proper use of cigarettes is lung cancer. A relatively little-known fact about shale gas production is that it produces considerable amounts of radioactive waste (Warner et al. 2013). Even the truck drivers disposing of this radio- active waste are not aware that their truckload is radioactive (Nobel 2020). We have seen with digital technologies such as social media and machine learning, that things seen as dark sides – discrimination in applications and data sources or cognitive distraction – are part of the constitutions of technologies. It is convenient for innovators to label negative consequences as ‘unintended’, but they may be designed into the system – features, not bugs – or they may be deliberately unanticipated to avoid accountability (Stilgoe 2020).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.