Puerto Rico should have social security
Racine et al 21 (Karl Racine, the former and first-elected Attorney General of Washington, D.C. leads bet-the-company litigation, investigations, and enforcement actions, while also leading the firm’s State Attorneys General practice. “Dear SCOTUS, 3.5 Million Americans in territories deserve same federal benefits,” AP Newsroom, 11/9/21, https://oag.dc.gov/release/op-ed-dear-scotus-35-million-americans-territories)//sz
What do Puerto Rico, Guam, the U.S. Virgin Islands, the Northern Mariana Islands and American Samoa all have in common? They , like Supplemental Security Income and food stamps that lift families and children out of poverty.
By now, you’re thinking that there must be a good explanation for why 3.5 million American citizens – 98% of whom are – are excluded from these benefits.
Think again.
The exclusion of the territories – and in some cases – from federal assistance is directly linked to racist and discredited theories about colonial governance that remain the law of the land. In the early 1900s, the Supreme Court ruled that new territories coming into the union would not be afforded the same constitutional protections as the states in a series of decisions known as the "."
In the Supreme Court’s own words, the newly acquired island territories were not governed by “” and their islands were inhabited by “alien races” and “savages.”
One can brush aside those racist caricatures as historical relics, however, the underlying rationale has tangible impacts today. Americans who live in certain territories are ineligible for Social Security Supplemental Income (SSI), Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF), the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) and more. Congress’ haphazard exclusion of the territories from national aid programs is permitted by the Insular Cases, which remain the law of the land.
Righting a wrong
For starters, the exclusion of the territories from these programs exacerbates poverty. To put territory poverty rates into perspective, the national hovers around 11.4%. At the state level, the poverty rates of the neediest states – Louisiana and Mississippi – 19%, according to the U.S. Census Bureau Dashboard.
However, nearly 23% of Guamanians live in poverty, according to the 2019 . And in and , the poverty rates are 43.5% and nearly 60%, respectively. Clearly, there is a real need for these programs, yet the Americans who need them the most are excluded.
And to make matters worse, there is no to which territories can receive which benefit. For example, the Northern Mariana Islands is the only territory where residents can receive SSI, and it is also the only territory where they are excluded from TANF. The SNAP , but not Puerto Rico, American Samoa or the Northern Mariana Islands.
It’s almost as if Congress drew names out of a hat to determine which territory received which program.