Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Degrowth is a privilege of the bourgeois, it does not consider those that are less fortunate.

Correira, 12. (David Correira; His work, whether in the archives, on the street, or in the classroom, focuses on the state's police powers, law and its relation to violence, and environmental politics. He is a co-founder of the research and mutual aid collective AbolishAPD (abolishapd.org).; February, 2012; “Degrowth, American Style: No Impact Man and Bourgeois Primitivism”; https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10455752.2011.648847?journalCode=rcns20; Taylor and Francis Online; Accessed 7/24/2023; JB)

The point of this essay has been to argue that the enormous popularity of No Impact Man, along with its critique[s] of mainstream environmentalism, means that a critical politics of anti-consumption as part of a transformation in socio-ecological relations must take bourgeois primitivism seriously. Otherwise bourgeois primitivism, like mainstream environmentalism before it, will offer capital the environmental legitimacy it requires to resolve crises and restructure the terms of access to nature and labor. Degrowth, as of yet, has not done this. For the remainder of the essay, I offer a brief summary of six areas where it could.

First, the focus of bourgeois primitivism on material objects has eclipsed a concern for structural processes, the role of political institutions and the politics of scale and space. This, I would argue, is a function of seeing the city, and all the privileges that the capitalist city bestows on its affluent residents, as an ontology of space, a pre-existing politics that makes challenging the socio-ecological foundation of capitalist relations impossible through a bourgeois primitivist lens. Bourgeois primitivist environmental political philosophy considers the social costs and collapse of economic restructuring only in terms of individual happiness and bourgeois socio-ecological security. Left without a critical vision of the uneven distribution of social and environmental costs, Beavan’s environmental politics is an aspatial, asocial politics. Therefore primitivist answers to environmental problems can only be located in certain privileged subjectivities of consumption.

If No Impact Man demonstrates anything, however, it is the political possibility of anti-consumption to transform individual subjectivities. In the documentary, the practice of anti-consumption, though individual in nature, brought Beavan increasingly into contact with people, institutions, and radical politics that transformed an initial commitment to reduce waste in order to ‘‘save the earth,’’ to one that included a nascent concern for environmental justice. While Beavan’s personal political transformation is important (offering up the possibility of a radical transformation of bourgeois environmental politics at least among certain ‘‘consumers’’), a more important question remains: Does the bourgeois primitivism of No Impact Man offer in itself a revolutionary path for the socio-ecological transformation of society? The short answer is, in its current expression, probably not. Food quality, not hunger or food insecurity, preoccupy bourgeois primitivist thinking. Quality of life, not day-to-day survival, is its rarefied concern. The lens of bourgeois primitivism is not calibrated to register the relational nature of class privilege and socionature. Therefore, if the politics of consumption are to be made a transformative force in socio-ecological change, and if the goal is to reveal the socio-ecological consequences of capitalist relations, then Degrowth must offer a compelling analysis of the problems of bourgeois primitivist privilege and define the forces driving ‘‘right-sizing’’ in ways distinct from those offered by Beavan.

Second, in order for Degrowth to develop this critique of bourgeois primitivist environmentalism, it must begin by first demonstrating where it differs from it. Despite some obvious differences offered above, there is much in common between Degrowth and bourgeois primitivism. For example, both elaborate an environmental vision of ‘‘living differently to live better’’ that places individuals at the privileged center of environmental politics. In addition, progress remains at the center of both notions but, importantly, for both it is a ‘‘[p]rogressing backwards,’’ as Latouche (2003) put it, that is important. And neither emphasizes a technocratic notion of progress.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.