Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchMichigan2023Disadvantage
Opening Word document…

Carbon tax lowers oil demand

Nick Macaluso et al 18, Environment and Climate Change Canada, NERA Economic Consulting, RTI International, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. "THE IMPACT OF CARBON TAXATION AND REVENUE RECYCLING ON U.S. INDUSTRIES," PubMed Central (PMC), https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7050298/, accessed 7-23-2023 | AKG

Putting a price on carbon emissions is intended to reduce the demand for fossil fuel-based energy sources and encourage the use of low or nonemitting energy sources such as natural gas, renewables (e.g., hydro, wind, solar, etc.) and nuclear. A carbon tax increases the cost of fossil fuels that emit more carbon encouraging consumers and businesses to switch to other, often cleaner fuels. Although these fuels may be initially more expensive, the higher price induces users to use lower-carbon energy sources, reduce energy use, or use energy more efficiently. The EMF 32 modeling and cross model comparison results are consistent with this theory. Modeling results clearly show that implementing a carbon tax lowers the demand for emissions-intensive energy sources such as coal and oil, while it increases the demand for relatively less emissions-intensive energy sources such as natural gas and renewables.

For EMF 32, the U.S. Energy Information Administration’s (EIA) Annual Energy Outlook 2016 reference scenario excluding the Clean Power Plan guides the baseline behavior for almost all models.6 Despite this harmonization, there is variation in primary energy use across the models. In addition, four models (DIEM, G-Cubed, IGEM, and ADAGE-US) focus on fossil fuels and do not explicitly account for renewables in the model. This could have consequences on compliance costs.

Figure 1 depicts primary energy demand by fuel and sector under the reference case and the carbon tax scenario for the 10 participating modeling teams (i.e., ADAGE-US, CEPE, DIEM, EC-MSMR, FARM, G-Cube, IGEM, NEMS, NewERA, and USREP-ReEDS). With respect to the carbon tax scenarios, the figure depicts results for the following four carbon tax trajectories under the lump-sum rebate to households revenue recycling option: (i) $25/tonne increasing at 1%/year; (ii) $25/tonne increasing at 5%/year; (iii) $50/tonne increasing at 1%/year; and (iv) $50/tonne increasing at 5%/year.

Figure 1.

Impact of carbon pricing on primary energy demand (exajoules per year).

The EMF 32 cross-model comparison shows that without any new carbon taxes primary energy steadily increases during the period 2020–2040 to support economic growth. Total primary energy usage grows at an average annual rate of 0.3% per year to reach 98 exajoules by 2040.7 From 2020 to 2040, this represents a cumulative increase of 7%. Of this total, −5.0% comes from coal (17 exajoules), 19% from natural gas (32 exajoules), 2% from oil (39 exajoules), and 20% (10 exajoules) from nonfossil fuels, which includes hydropower, nuclear, and renewable fuels. The fuel-specific values vary across the models.8

Focusing on the model specific change in primary energy between 2020 and 2040, seven of the models (CEPE, DIEM, FARM, G-Cubed, IGEM, NEMS and NewERA) assumed that primary energy would increase in the range of 0.3% to 0.4% per year, while USREP-ReEDS assumed a growth of 0.02%. The EC-MSMR suggests a decline of 0.5% per year. Unlike the other models, whose reference cases are closely aligned to the AEO2016 forecast, the EC-MSMR reference case is aligned to a version of the AEO2015 (which includes the impacts of the Clean Power Plan as reported in the 2016 Second Biennial Report of the United States of America9).

Each model, except EC-MSMR, shows a consistent pattern of overall growth in primary energy use, although the growth rates of the specific primary fuels vary. Four of the models (DIEM, G-Cubed, IGEM, and ADAGE-US) do not report nonfossil fuel primary energy sources. By 2040, these models suggest that the share of coal and oil (in total primary energy use) declines, while the share of natural gas increases. USREP-ReEDS projects the greatest decline in coal’s share of total primary demand (−5.2%), followed by the ADAGE-US (−2.7%), while ADAGE-US and IGEM project the greatest decline in the share of oil (−3.2%) followed by G-Cubed (−2.6%). With respect to natural gas, ADAGE-US (5.8%) and IGEM/G-Cubed (5.1%) project an increase in its share.

There is also variation among the models that include both fossil fuels and renewables. For example, EC-MSMR (0.3%) projects an increase in coal’s share of total primary energy, while the other models show decreases ranging from FARM 3.1 (1.1%) and USREP-ReEDS (5.2%). While most models show a decline in oil’s share, two show an increase — FARM 3.1 (2.6%) and USREP-ReEDS (2.0%). With respect to hydro, CEPE projects an increasing share (0.5%), while FARM 3.1 suggests a decreasing share (−0.1%). NEMS projects the greatest increase in solar (1.0%). There is also variation in the changing shares of wind and biomass.

Figure 1 also shows that implementing a carbon tax will lower the demand for emission intensive energy sources such as coal and oil, while increasing the demand for energy sources such as natural gas and renewables. This is consistent with other studies (e.g., Hafstead and Picciano, 2017; Aldy, 2013). In general, $50/tonne would add about 44 cents to a gallon of gasoline, 51 cents to a gallon of diesel, $2.65 per MMBtu of natural gas, while coal prices would increase between $63 and $129 per tonne depending on the type of coal being used.10

The cross-model comparison shows that as the carbon price increases, the level of primary energy usage, especially the use of coal, declines. One exception is the EC-MSMR model, which shows under moderately increasing carbon prices, integrated gasification combined cycle (IGCC) with capture is assumed to be competitive and this leads to an increase in coal use. The fuel share mix is in general consistent across the models; however, the magnitude of the impact increases with the increasing carbon prices. For example, average total primary demand across the models in 2040 is 67 exajoules ($50/tonne increasing at 5%/year scenario). This compares to 76 exajoules ($50/tonne increasing at 1%/year scenario). The $25/tonne scenario exhibits the same general pattern.

Focusing on specific model results, total primary energy demand ranges from 84 exajoules (ADAGE-US) to 48 exajoules (CEPE) under the $50/tonne increasing at 5%/year scenario, while it ranges from 94 exajoules (ADAGE-US) to 60 exajoules (CEPE) under the $50/tonne increasing at 1%/year scenario. The model results also suggest the importance of the availability of nonfossil fuels in the mix. The models that do not have the option to substitute to nonfossil fuels tend to have results showing larger net reductions in total primary energy use. This is mostly due to significant demand reduction for fossil fuels.

While the results clearly show that the carbon tax level does affect total primary energy usage, revenue recycling for each carbon level does not show the same influence. That is, different revenue recycling methods tend to generate similar levels of primary energy use for a given tax rate. This is consistent with other studies (e.g., Ecofiscal Commission, 2016). Figure 2 depicts change in primary energy demand for the various tax level and revenue recycling combinations.11 Revenue returned to households either as direct rebates (also called lump-sum transfers) designated by “HH”, while “K” designates cuts in the marginal tax rates on capital and “L” labor income.

Figure 2.

Change in primary energy demand from lump-sum rebate for capital and labor tax reductions, 2020–2040 (exajoules per year).

As illustrated in Fig. 2, all models suggested that the tax level could reduce primary fossil energy demand in aggregate. With respect to coal, all but one model (i.e., EC-MSMR) suggest that primary coal demand under the “core” carbon tax scenarios will be lower than the reference level demand. The results from EC-MSMR are influenced by the fact that coal with CCS is competitive in the carbon tax scenarios and as such, there is a switch from coal without CCS to coal with CCS. With respect to primary oil demand, virtually all models suggest that oil demand will be lower than the reference level demand. With respect to natural gas, three models (e.g., NewERA, NEMS, and USREP-ReDS) suggest that there is a carbon price range where natural gas is higher than the reference case.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.