U.S. security cooperation is the key factor.
Quencez ’21 — Martin; Research Fellow in the Security & Defense Program, Associate Researcher for the European Council on Foreign Relations, PhD Candidate in Contemporary History at the Sorbonne Nouvelle University. September 22, 2021; “The US cannot escape the European strategic autonomy debate”; The Progressive Post; https://progressivepost.eu/the-us-cannot-escape-the-european-strategic-autonomy-debate/
The US, however, plays a more ambiguous part, and appears as the elephant in the room in most European discussions. In fact, European strategic autonomy is still very much about the US. Despite many attempts to consolidate and expand the concept to broader issues, the inertia of this debate is a perfect illustration of the inability of transatlantic partners to reform and recalibrate their relationship in order to adapt to the 21st century geopolitical environment.
The balance of power within the transatlantic security and defence partnership provides the framework for the strategic autonomy discussion. Within the alliance, the US remains a security provider, while European powers are mostly security benefiters. US political leaders — from Eisenhower to Trump — have repeatedly criticised European “security free-riding”, but their European counterparts were less than eager to change this comfortable position.
The concept of strategic autonomy has only recently gained traction in Europe when the dependency on the US has become more difficult to sustain. The evolution of the security environment in Europe and its Eastern and Southern neighbourhoods over the past ten years, as well as the growing unpredictability of US politics have led some Europeans to think that they could no longer rely on others to solve their problems.