Investments in education not only increase economic growth but are crucial to the future.
Saima Bashir et al 2012 (Saima Bashir is a professor of business administration at Central State University. She has a PhD in Natural Resource Economics. Janaranjana Herath is an associate professor and a researcher in the fields of agricultural economics, health economics, business management, and finance at West Virginia University. He has a PhD in Natural Resource Economics. Tesfa Gebremedhin is a professor emeritus of resource economics and management at West Virginia University, “An Empirical Analysis of Higher Education and Economic Growth in West Virginia,” Agricultural and Applied Economics Association, https://ageconsearch.umn.edu/record/124829/) –cpstk
Investment in education to increase economic growth, as one form of human development strategy, has gained economists‟ and policy makers‟ interest. It establishes human capital that makes a substantial contribution to economic and income growth. Its contribution returns in the form of skilled labor which leads to increased development and improved quality of life. Different theories and models have been used to examine the relationship between education and economic growth. Most of them concentrated on human capital accumulation as source of acceleration in economic growth. Some of them used human capital as an engine of economic growth to technological change. But for human accumulation, a country should invest more on education. Thus, the main objective of the study is to analyze the relationship between higher education growth and economic growth in West Virginia. A set of simultaneous equations with three endogenous variables namely, per capita income change, education change and population change were used for the analysis. Empirical results indicate that income growth and education growth are positively related while education growth reduces population growth in West Virginia. 1. Introduction Investment in education to increase economic growth, as one form of human development strategy, has gained economists‟ and policy makers‟ interest (Johnson, 2011). Investment in education preserves returns in the form of skilled labor which leads to increased development and improved quality of life (Yogish, 2006). Investment in education not only benefits individuals through income but also benefit economy as a whole through skilled labor who increase competition and economic growth (Alam, 2009). The relationship between education and economic growth was first developed by Adam Smith, followed by Marshall, Schultz, Bowman and others (Pradhan, 2009). Empirical estimation of the relationship dated back to 1957 when Robert Solow estimated the contribution of labor, capital and technological change to economic growth in the United States over the period 1909-1949 (Chaudhary et al., 2009; Matsushita et al., 2006). Different theories and models have used to examine the relationship between education and economic growth (Romer, 1990; Chakraborty, 2005). Most of them concentrated on human capital accumulation as a source of acceleration in economic growth. Some of them used human capital as an engine of economic growth to technological change. Individuals and society gained economic benefits because of higher education gained by individuals (Krueger and Lingahl, 2001). It benefits to society both on micro and macro level. It affects the economic system directly and indirectly, where a rise in individual‟s wage is a direct effect and an increase in education is an indirect effect (Heckman and Klenow, 1997; Pradhan, 2009). Economists and policy makers face the problem of low level of skilled labor in countries which are trying to increase their economic growth (McClelland, 1966). According to policy makers and economists, countries or states should spend a significant amount on education for their population, which will increase income significantly and leads to strengthen the economy (Krueger and Lingahl, 2001). Thus, the main objective of this study is to analyze the relationship between economic growth and higher education in West Virginia. The paper is organized into six sections. Section 2 describes the background information of West Virginia. Section 3 provides the literature review. Section 4 covers the methodology and data sources. Section 5 describes the empirical results and analysis. Section 6 presents the summary and conclusions. 2. Background of the study area West Virginia, one of the rural states, has low educational attainment and high unemployment rate (US Census Bureau, 2010). Nearly 44 percent of the population lives in rural areas. The average population density is about 75 people per square mile and the per capita personal income was $32,219 in 2009, which was 17.7 percent below the national per capita income of $39,138 (Hammond, 2012). The average per capita income in the rural area was $29,200 compared to $33,578 in the urban area in 2008 (ERS-USDA, 2008). Nearly 24 percent of the total land area is used for farming (ERS, 2011). Approximately 3.7 million acres are farmlands with 23,200 farms and average farm size is 159 acres (USDA/NASS, 2010). Apart from agriculture, manufacturing, services, mining and tourism (an emerging sector) are currently the major economic sectors in West Virginia (ERS, 2011). West Virginia has relatively low higher education rates, high unemployment rates (Gebremeriam et al., 2006), low per capita income compared to other states in Appalachian region (Appalachian Regional Commission, 2010a ). The economic status of 22 counties is “Transitional,” 20 counties “At Risk”, 11 counties “Distressed,” and 2 counties “Competitive” in West Virginia. Thirty – four of total 55 counties are located within rural (non-metropolitan) areas (Appalachian Regional Commission, 2010a ). The slow growth of income and employment, large out-migration are the major reflections of persistently high rates of poverty in West Virginia (US Census Bureau, 2010). This is related to less job opportunities and is a hazard to economic growth of West Virginia (D‟Souza and Gebremedhin, 1999). According to Herndon (2008), expenditures on investment in education for human capital formation have increased in West Virginia, but the number of higher education graduates working within the state have decreased over time (Hammond, 2012). 3. Literature Review The role of education has been acknowledged widely by economists and policy makers (Gilead, 2012). The utilization of infrastructure and technology requires a leading role of higher education system in regional economic development (Schlottmann, 2010). Economists believe that investment on education or human capital increases output and labor productivity. Investment in human capital is crucial in the future because the economy is turning into knowledge-based from post-industrial economy (Dickens et al., 2006). Teles and Andrade (2004) estimated the relationship between government spending on basic education and economic growth. Results revealed that economic decision makings of an agent are affected by his/her educational level. Jorgenson and Fraumeni (1992) estimated the impact of investment in education on U.S. economic growth. They used data from 1948 to 1969. Results revealed that an appropriate value of investment in education was given by its impact on lifetime labor income of an individual. Hanushek and Wobmann (2007) examined the role of education in promoting economic well-being focusing on the role of educational quality. Results showed that cognitive skills of population have strong relationship with individual earnings, distribution of income, and economic growth. Barro (2001) studied on education as a measure of human capital in his study. Results showed that economic growth is positively related to starting level of average years of school attainment of adult males at the secondary and higher level. Results further revealed that the quality of school education and its impact on economic growth is different among rich and poor countries. Investment in education and health services are the major factors for human capital development and the subsequent impact on economic growth. However, economic growth is also the main source for human capital development. Ranis et al. (2000) estimated the effects of economic growth as the result of human capital development and the effects of human capital development as the result of economic growth. Results showed that economic growth had positive and strong impact on human capital development. Results also showed that significant and strong GDP per capita income growth leads to higher human capital development. Dowrick (2002) reviewed empirical studies that examined the relationship between economic growth and education and R&D (Research and Development). These studies showed that education and R&D are substantial sources to promote economic growth. Participation in education and public expenditures on education increased during 19th and 20th centuries. Enrolment in public education system has increased by 40 percent from 1870 to 2001 whereas public expenditure on education increased from 0.86 percent to 4.85 percent of GDP during the same time period. GDP also increased nine times in the same time period (Carpentier, 2006). Previous studies revealed that investment in education resulted in economic benefits. However, the size and margin of these benefits vary by race, gender, and ethnicity. Graph 1 below represents unemployment rate by race. Unemployment rate decreases from 13.9 percent to 4.5 percent in black population if individuals completed their bachelor degrees or higher. There is 5 per cent reduction in unemployment rate in white population for completing the same degree (Williams and Swail, 2005). Education has an influence on crime rate in several ways. First, education increases the opportunity cost of crime due to higher wage rate. Second, educated people are more patient and less risk takers. Third, attending school keeps young people busy and reduces criminal participation (Lochner and Moretti, 2003). One good reason to increase policymakers‟ interest in education to raise the economy of metro areas is to encourage students to stay in the region or attract others to come from outside to the region (Bartik and Erickcek, 2007).