Federalism is critical to successful environmental policy
Stan Meiburg, 4-26-2021, Ph.D. is the Director of the Graduate Studies in Sustainability at Wake Forest University and a Fellow at the National Academy of Public Administration, American Federalism and the Environment – FEDERALISM.US," Federalism.US a place for policy makers, researchers and citizens interested in analyzing and better understanding issues related to federalism, intergovernmental relations and multilevel democracy.
, https://federalism.us/2021/04/american-federalism-and-the-environment/, Accessed: 6-24-2021, /Kent Denver-MB
To a degree unprecedented in recent American history, the environment, especially but not limited to climate change, has moved to the front rank of our public policy concerns. Even more remarkable is the degree to which this concern is interwoven with other threads: economic recovery, racial and social justice, energy supply and demand, trade policy, financial investments, agricultural policy, and national security.
This attention reminds us of the rise of the environmental movement over fifty years ago, symbolized by the prominence of Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring and the first Earth Day, April 22, 1970. Among the most significant consequences of that rise was the creation by then-President Nixon of a new federal organization, the United States Environmental Protection Agency, a combination of parts from fifteen agencies around the government. The new agency, known universally by its acronym, EPA, opened its doors on December 2, 1970, headed by a 38-year-old former state senator from Indiana, William Ruckelshaus.
The following twenty years witnessed a tremendous expansion in federal environmental law. Congress passed and Presidents signed into law twenty major pieces of environmental legislation, including such landmarks as the Clean Air Act, the Clean Water Act, and Safe Drinking Water Act, the Toxic Substances Control Act, the Ocean Dumping Act, and the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act (better known as “Superfund”). Though many challenges remain, today we are the beneficiaries of these initiatives in the form of cleaner air, water and land. To cite one set of statistics: since 1970, real GDP has increased by 285%, we drive almost three times as many miles, we have added more than 125 million people to our population, and we use 48% more energy; yet our emissions of the so-called “criteria pollutants” –hydrocarbons, particles, sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxides, lead and carbon monoxide–have decreased by 77%.
Though federal leadership has been essential, this success is not the result of unilateral federal action. Federalism has been at the heart of much of this progress and of many of its most intense controversies. The private sector and non-governmental organizations have both played vital roles, but the interplay of federal and state action has been and remains a hallmark of U.S. environmental policy.
Like most federalism discussions, this one starts with the Constitution. EPA has broad authorities derived from the enumerated powers given to Congress in the commerce clause. This clause has been broadly interpreted through the years, but debates persist over its scope, as evidenced by current arguments about the jurisdiction of the Clean Water Act over the “navigable waters” of the United States.
Apart from constitutional issues, the expansion of federal environmental law between 1970 and 1990 rested upon a parallel framework which President Nixon referred to as “the new federalism”. This new federalism contrasted with previous expansions of federal authority in the Progressive Era, the New Deal, and the Great Society by explicitly giving significant discretion to states in the administration of federal statutes. With the notable exceptions of Superfund and TSCA, the major environmental statutes provide for states to implement their permitting and enforcement authorities.
The organization of EPA reflects this difference. EPA is decentralized, in that almost half of its staff reside in ten regional offices, located in standard federal region cities. However, unlike the Park Service, the Forest Service, the USDA extension service, the Natural Resources Conservation Service, the Federal Housing Administration, the Federal Highway Administration, or the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, EPA with few exceptions does not have staff stationed in state capitals or in field locations. EPA delegates authorities that such staff might exercise to state environmental agencies. States acquire these authorities by seeking delegation or approval from EPA, according to the provisions of the various environmental statutes. By and large this process was completed over thirty years ago, and it is fair to speak now of a U.S. environmental enterprise where governance is shared between states and EPA (and, to an increasing degree, tribal authorities).