Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

And/or has definite meaning of “A or B or both” legally, despite misuse and attacks on “ambiguity.”

Robbins 18

Ira P. Robbins 5 – 7- 18 (Professor at AU's Washington College of Law, is an expert on criminal law and procedure, the death penalty, habeas corpus, prisoners' rights, privatization of prisons and jails, conspiracy, insanity, and other legal issues. He was Acting Director of the Federal Judicial Center's Education and Training Division and served as the reporter for the American Bar Association's Task Force on Death Penalty Habeas Corpus and its Task Force on Privatization of Corrections. Professor Robbins also served as a Supreme Court Fellow and as a special consultant to the Advisory Committee on Criminal Rules of the Judicial Conference of the United States. In 2008, Professor Robbins was named a member of the American Bar Association Task Force on Post-Conviction Remedies. Professor Robbins is a founding member of the WCL Criminal Justice Practice & Policy Institute. His recent books include Habeas Corpus Checklists (2023) and Prisoners and the Law (six vols., 2023). His publications have been cited in more than 100 judicial opinions, including by the U.S. Supreme Court and the High Court of Israel. Professor Robbins' interviews and analyses have appeared on all of the major U.S. and foreign television and radio networks (including The Colbert Report, on Comedy Central) and in such publications as Time, Newsweek, U.S. News & World Report, HuffPost, London Times, New York Times, New York Times Magazine, New Yorker, Politico, USA Today, Wall Street Journal, Washington Post, ABA Journal, National Law Journal, and Legal Times. Robbins' recent media attention has focused on his work on the doctrine of citizen's arrest, particularly regarding the murder of Ahmaud Arbery in Georgia. In 2016, in recognition of his scholarship and testimony opposing private prisons since their inception, Professor Robbins was elected to the Board of Directors of Abolish Private Prisons. The aim of the organization is to eliminate private prisons in the U.S. by challenging their constitutionality. Professor Robbins was also named legal consultant to the litigation team. Professor Robbins' honors and awards include the Chief Judge John R. Brown Award for Judicial Scholarship and Education (1998). He is also an Elected Life Member of the American Law Institute (2007). At American University, he received the University Faculty Award for Outstanding Teaching (1985) and was selected as American University’s Scholar/Teacher of the Year (1988), the University’s highest faculty award. In 2010, Professor Robbins won the Pauline Ruyle Moore Award, in recognition of his scholarly work in the area of public law. In 2011, he was selected as the first recipient of the Washington College of Law Award for Exemplary Teaching. In 2015, he was honored with the Washington College of Law Award for Outstanding Service. Apart from his law-related endeavors, Professor Robbins is an award-winning photographer.) “'And/Or' and the Proper Use of Legal Language” American University Washington College of Law 7 – 2- 23 https://www.wcl.american.edu/impact/lawwire/and-or-and-the-proper-use-of-legal-language/ //EKoo

The use of the term and/or is pervasive in legal language. Lawyers use it in all types of legal contexts — including statutes, contracts, and pleadings. Beginning in the 1930s, however, many judges decided that the term and/or should never be used in legal drafting. Ardent attacks on the term included charges that it was vague, if not meaningless, with some authorities declaring it to be a “Janus-faced verbal monstrosity,” an “inexcusable barbarism,” a “mongrel expression,” an “abominable invention,” a “crutch of sloppy thinkers,” and “senseless jargon.” Still today, critics maintain that the construct and/or is inherently ambiguous and should be avoided whenever possible — which, many detractors would argue, is always.

And/or, however, is not ambiguous at all. It has a definite, agreed-upon meaning: when used properly, the construct means “A or B or both.” In most areas of law, there simply is no compelling reason to avoid using and/or. The term is clear and concise. It derives criticism mainly from the inability of people to use it correctly. Pleadings, contracts, statutes, and patent claims all allow for a cogent use of and/or. Conversely, some legal areas — such as jury instructions, search warrants, and jury verdicts — do not typically allow a drafter to provide options, making and/or unsuitable.

Despite the few contexts in which and/or should be avoided, the construct should not be discarded simply because individuals occasionally misuse the term. After all, legal drafters and courts commonly struggle with using and interpreting “and” and “or,” words that themselves are riddled with ambiguity. And/or has a precise meaning; it allows for the possibility of conveying options in the alternative. As with many consistent errors in legal writing, the problem lies not with the term and/or itself, but with a lack of close attention to detail. Legal drafters should use it with the same level of care with which they use any other word or phrase.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.