Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The politics of the 1AC uses market social institutions as a vessel to exclude the individual from society. Their appeal to social welfare programs inverts Keynesian economics, forcing the market to implement socially uplifting policy. This fails

Bohl 12 [Kenneth Bohl, PhD in Philosophy at Duquesne University, CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY: ENGAGING COMMUNICATIVE PRAXIS IN AN ERA OF NEOCLASSICAL ECONOMICS, https://media.proquest.com/media/hms/ORIG/2/wIMBK?_s=QABOCX6qK1jKGkwqEuLul0eNTUY%3D, LTEC]

Keynes had great concerns regarding individualism, self-interest, and the ability of laissez-faire to provide for public social interests the world is not so governed from above that private and social interest always coincide. It is not so managed here below that in practice they coincide. It is not a correct deduction from the principles of economics that enlightened self-interest always operates in the public interest. Nor is it true that self-interest generally is enlightened; more often individuals 15 acting separately to promote their own ends are too ignorant or too weak to attain even these. (Keynes, Laissez-faire loc. 360) Keynes spoke of the need to separate "those services which are technically social from those that are technically individual" (Laissez-faire loc. 449) (emphasis his). "Technically social" services are those that remain unprovided unless provided by the State. Keynes furthermore advocated for the central control of currency as well as "full publicity, by law if necessary, of all business facts which it is useful to know" (loc. 449), a precursor to CSR's call for corporate transparency. The Keynesian legacy also laid the groundwork in the United States for such social welfare programs as social security, unemployment insurance, and Medicare that would not have otherwise existed except for the intervention of the government. These social welfare programs represent an economic social responsibility to protect the vulnerable of our society—those who are unable to provide for themselves (Goodin 145). The function of the welfare state is for the government to provide services to those who are not otherwise provided for. In other words "the state should become responsible whenever there is no one with primary responsibility, or whenever those with primary responsibility are unable or unwilling to discharge it" (Goodin 151). The United States has a long history of providing such services. These services extend beyond social security, unemployment compensation, or Medicare and include children and youth services as well as foreign aid. During the period of Keynesian economics, national social welfare programs expanded at a considerable rate. The welfare state is defined by Agnar Sandmo as "the economic and social policies of a country that gives high priorities to equality and individual protection against social hazards" (469). Although taken as a 16 given right, public education—advocated as a government responsibility by Adam Smith—is another example of a social welfare program. Sandmo states that it is not just wealth redistribution programs such as social security or unemployment that make up a welfare state, but also the presence of economic policies that work to reduce the need for welfare, such as federal jobs programs or employee education programs. According to Robert Goodin, the welfare state and welfare economics represent a social responsibility of a government to protect the vulnerable, such as children, the elderly, the infirm, the impoverished, or the disabled. This is a position that was advocated first by Adam Smith and reinvigorated by John Maynard Keynes but, beginning in the 1980s, had come under increasing fire. Richard Clayton and Jonas Pontusson report that during the Ronald Reagan and George H. W. Bush presidencies, Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC) benefits were cut 31% (86). AFDC benefits were further cut during the Bill Clinton administration by $24 billion. Social welfare programs represent one aspect of economic social responsibility. Neoclassical economic theory would have us believe that those theories are value neutral, and yet there is a broad spectrum of social values to which economics must respond. That there are social responsibilities for which economics must answer is not a new construct but rather originates in the writings of Adam Smith, who himself draws on the virtue ethics of Aristotle. By and large, the welfare state has remained intact during the past decades, although there has been increasing pressure to reform welfare by either reducing obligations or shifting the obligation to the private sector. However, the reason for the existence of social welfare originates in the lack of resources in the private sphere for these specific needs and hence the need for non-market social institutions. 17 Prior to Keynes, the prevailing belief was that there could not be such a thing as long term structural unemployment (Goodin 148). This belief contributed to the view that, by and large, unemployment was a voluntary condition. The Great Depressions of the late 18th and early 19th centuries, of course, proved otherwise. Under the mantle of Keynesian economic theory, President Franklin Delano Roosevelt began his extensive public works projects, and under the same mantle President Lyndon Johnson implemented his works of the Great Society. Both the New Deal of President Roosevelt and the Great Society projects of President Johnson contributed to the welfare of society through the creation of public works jobs that not only built national infrastructure but also worked to preserve and restore the environment. Neoclassical economic theory would challenge the social welfare position of Keynesian economics.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.