Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Neoclassical economic policies only push self-interest, they leave no room for poverty alleviation.

Chiti 10, Leonard Chiti, SJ, 2010, Chiti is director of the Jesuit Centre for Theological Reflection in Lusaka, Zambia. “Markets, Inequality, and Poverty” BHO

Neoclassical economic theory assumes that a given rate of growth of GDP translates into poverty reduction. Increases in GDP in any given country represent the best route towards lifting people out of poverty. Such growth maybe accompanied by rapid rates of industrialization giving rise to new jobs, increasing incomes and improving the living standards of the poor.33 According to this line of thinking growth occurs when market forces are allowed to determine the prices of different products on the market to stimulate productivity and innovation. Consequently, a self-regulating market economy responding to price signals is able to stimulate economic activities driven by supply and demand forces to ensure that economic actors pursue self interests that culminate in economic growth. Narrow economic interests are primary and no other considerations are allowed to play a part in economic endeavours. Neoliberal economic policies believe that the State is an inefficient and ineffective actor in allocating scarce resources. The assumption is that the market is a better instrument at allocating resources.34 Neoliberal economic models are predicated on the existence of free and perfect markets. These markets allow free entry and exit of economic actors into the market. This facilitates market forces to play the role of determining prices and consequently allocating resources according to the dictates of supply and demand. The logic of markets embedded in neoclassical economics is predicated on the assumption that economic actors are motivated and solely preoccupied with maximizing utility. Consequently an economy can only reach optimal efficiency when there is no attempt to regulate self-interested economic actors. This kind of economics would go so far as to posit that those who are poor and unemployed have failed to take advantage of market opportunities to earn a livelihood. In its purist form classical and neoclassical economic theory does not have a place for poverty alleviation programs particularly the type that are undertaken by the State. Neoclassical economists see poverty reduction efforts as slowing down growth.36 This in some ways explains the neoclassical economists’ antipathy towards the State’s intervention in the economy. For neoclassical economists the market is superior to the State in resource allocation and therefore the latter should be limited in its interventions in the economy. Market fundamentalists are obsessed with growth. Growth comes from the entrepreneurial activity of a rational economic actor operating in an enabling environment. There is no questioning that growth is necessary for development and that markets can play an important role in facilitating this growth. However, growth for its own sake is not a sufficient condition for development and poverty reduction. What is crucial is to recognize the limitations of both the State and markets in development activities.37 The State, however, can play a meaning role in limiting or even compensating for market failures. Perhaps the basic question that can be asked is ‘What can government do best?.38 Neoclassical economic theory fails to take into account the fact that markets can experience failures. For markets to work efficiently several conditions need to occur such as perfect information, unhindered entry and exit into the market, perfect competition just to mention a few. Seldom are many of these conditions met. Consequently, market failures are common particularly in Low Development Countries.39 It has been frequently stated that the market is a good servant but a bad master.Left to itself it cannot guarantee the integral development of every human being. What is required is to harness the good side of the market, as represented its ability to generate wealth, and reject its bad side which is seen mostly in its unintended effects such as increase in inequalities. Neoclassic economic theory with its attendant methodological individualism places a heavy premium on a rational actor pursuing self-interest in a bid to maximise material well-being. This displays a reductionist world view where everything is reduced to economic interests. This effectively rules any other way of conceiving human well being. A flawed vision of the world. Neoliberalism’s worldview revolves around material concerns. The basic quest for rational beings is to achieve as much material success as possible. When human beings are given the freedom to pursue their private interests aided by the price mechanism society benefits from increased growth of the economy41 Their anthropology is founded on the notion that human beings are solely preoccupied with the pursuit of economic self-interest. This vision of the world is flawed. It is purely a mechanistic worldview that gives too much responsibility to the market to address the society’s challenges. Much of the conflict between the proponents and opponents of the market stems from differing ideological positions. The former have received backing from conservative political forces believe that society’s challenges can be resolved by strengthening the rights of individuals to pursue individual interests. Conservatives who espouse capitalist approach to economic activity believe that negative freedoms such as the right to non-interference to economic actors to participate in economic affairs should be strengthened in order to enable the fruits of such endeavours to ‘trickle down’ to the rest of society. On the other hand, civil society perspectives that the rights of individuals should be matched with their corresponding duties to aid the collective should be retained and promoted. The market cannot assure these rights only the State can guarantee them. The goal of development from a neoliberal point of view is to increase the nations’ GDP. The higher the GDP the more prosperous the country is reckoned.42 However, GDP misses many aspects of our existence. Besides, much of the progress in important areas of life is invisible to most people.43 The neoliberal paradigm simply promotes the materialistic motivations of individuals.44 Ethical Concerns The main normative aspect of neoliberalism is the promotion of individual achievement and protection of negative rights45 Right wing political forces in the 1980s and early 1990s at the time of the hegemony market economy economic theories supported such approaches. However, as Allen and Thomas point out that social forces such as solidarity and other non-market forces play crucial roles in improving the living standards of the people.46 This would be in sharp contrast to the moral voice of the Church which encourages the promotion of social values. Commenting on the crisis that beset the capitalist world in 2008, Frank Turner wonders whether part of the problem of the Global Economic Crisis could not be ascribed to the absence of ‘a moral or systemic crisis’.47 It surely can be argued that the absence of ethical and moral consideration did play a part in the Financial crisis that engulfed much of the Western World in 2008. The greed and irresponsibility exhibited by some economic actors in these financial markets played a critical role in its unravelling. Neoclassical economic theory would consider this normal as part of the motivating factor of ‘rational self- interested’ economic actors. Ethical and moral concerns are important in the Christian approach to interactions in the market place. The Church Social Teaching is clear on the need to promote ethical values such as solidarity, the common good and a special concern for the poor48 The economy and by extension the market should serve the interest of those who are weak and unable to actively take advantage of the market to advance their economic and material interests. The market cannot guarantee this facilitate. And free markets cannot work in a moral vacuum.49 The State who primary responsibility is to promote the common good is expected to supplement the actions of the market. Such goods as shelter, health care, education, transport and welfare cannot be left to the market50 Civil society groups who oppose the self-regulating market in development activities point to similar concerns. As a practical example, the JCTR, a faith based organisation that engages in research, advocacy and education has always advocated for a value based approached to development endeavours. It employs the CST to call for the respect of human dignity and the promotion of human rights as a holistic approach to development. Such an approach recognises that the market on its own cannot deliver on development. The market is amoral and needs moral input to ensure that the ‘trickled down effect’ reaches all corners of society. Free markets need appropriate political direction to ensure that the goods of the earth are enjoyed by all its inhabitants. Conclusion The preceding sought to suggest that the theoretical assumptions underpinning the neoclassical economic theories are flawed. Neoliberal models of development advocated by pro-market fundamentalists in the 1980s and 1990s failed to lift the vast majority of people out of poverty. Such policies promoted by International Financial Institutions (IFIs) such as the World Bank and the IMF have done very little to significantly reduce poverty and narrow existing inequalities. CSOs including the church have been advocating a tempering of the push for market oriented reforms in order to less the adverse impact of neoliberal economic reforms.51 This essay attempted to show that different ways of perceiving the world yield different ways of intervening to bring about positive social change. A neoliberal worldview sees social change in terms of increasing aggregate wealth which then is redistributed by inhuman market forces to bring about a convergence in living standards between the rich and the poor. This way of perceiving the world has been found wanting. Economic growth does not necessarily lead to poverty reduction and declining inequality. The evidence adduced above suggest that in some cases economic growth does very little to change existing poverty situation and inequalities. Neoliberalism with its stress on individual action as a precursor to group welfare has not fared well in Zambia. Much of the failure of neoliberalism can be located in its universalist pretensions of what works in one place can work everywhere. The one –size fits all approach has now been discredited even though the fall of communism appeared to give a thumbs up to capitalism. In recent times, the once derided economic planning has made a comeback and the State has been reinstated in order to curb the excesses of the market and strengthen the distributive dimension of human well being.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.