They don’t have SSI rights.
Reyes 21 (Raul Reyes is a graduate of Harvard University and Columbia Law and an immigration lawyer, “In SSI case, Supreme Court should extend a lifeline to Puerto Rico” 11-08-2021 https://thehill.com/opinion/judiciary/580498-in-ssi-case-supreme-court-should-extend-a-lifeline-to-puerto-rico/) [CT]
It is not good policy to exclude Puerto Ricans from SSI. who live in Puerto Rico are American citizens. The island has a and of . While the territory has its own version of SSI, called Aid to the Aged, Blind, and Disabled, that program has more stringent eligibility requirements and pays out less in benefits. The average monthly benefit under Puerto Rico’s is $75 a month, while for on the mainland it is $591 a month. Plus, in recent years the island has been hit hard by a financial crisis, Hurricane Maria, and the COVID-19 pandemic.
Leading advocacy and Latino organizations like the , , and support Vaello-Madero’s position, as does the territory’s Republican . Guess who else thinks denying SSI benefits to Puerto Rico is a bad idea: whose Justice Department is pursuing the case against Vaello-Madero. “I believe that Puerto Rico residents should be able to receive SSI benefits,” the president said , calling the current exclusion of Puerto Rico from the program “inconsistent with my administration’s policies and values.”
Biden’s comments make his administration’s decision to perplexing. The president said that his administration was obligated to . This is not necessarily true; in 2011 to stop defending the Defense of Marriage Act because it did not align with his administration’s policy preferences.
The Biden administration’s is that reforming SSI should be left to Congress — as if the legislative body that has struggled to investigate an armed insurrection at the Capitol itself would ever take up the cause of vulnerable Puerto Ricans.
The administration that it would cost about $2 billion annually to make SSI available on the island, and notes that Puerto Rico residents do not pay federal income tax. But cost factors are not a legal basis for withholding benefits from citizens, and most of the people who qualify for SSI make too little to pay income tax anyway. The government’s unconvincing arguments aside, what’s at stake here is the well-being of needy Americans.