The affirmative’s demonizing Western representations of Asia reinscribes yellow peril which results in xenophobia, cultural deprivation, and racist stereotypes.
Siu & Chun 20 – [Associate Professor Asian American and Asian Diaspora Studies Chinese Diaspora, Cultural Citizenship, Cultural Politics of Food, Diaspora / Transnationalism; Asians in the Americas, Ethnography PhD, Anthropology, Stanford University, MA, Anthropology, Stanford University, BA, Anthropology, minor in Ethnic Studies, University of California, Berkeley **Ph.D. student at the University of California, Berkeley in the Department of Ethnic Studies, 19-2020 recipient of The Catherine and William L. Magistretti Graduate Fellowship, B.A. in Politics and Social and Cultural Analysis from New York University. [Lok, Claire, Yellow Peril and Techno-orientalism in the Time of Covid-19: Racialized Contagion, Scientific Espionage, and Techno-Economic Warfare, Journal of Asian American Studies, Volume 23, Number 3, October 2020, pp. 421-440 (Article)//olivia
In its inherent attempt to construct a racial other, “yellow peril” is more¶ a projection of Western fear than a representation of an Asian object/subject,¶ and in this sense, it may be better understood as a repository of racial¶ affect that can animate a myriad of representational figures, images, and¶ discourses, depending on context. Indeed, the images and discourses of¶ yellow peril have surfaced multiple times throughout the twentieth century,¶ capturing a multitude of ever-shifting perceived threats that range¶ from the danger of military intrusion (i.e., Japanese Americans during WWII),¶ economic competition (i.e., Chinese laborers in the late nineteenth century,¶ Japan in the 1980s), Asian moral and cultural depravity (i.e., non-Christian¶ heathens, Chinese prostitutes, opium smokers), to biological inferiority¶ (i.e., effeminacy, disease carriers). As Colleen Lye observes, “the incipient¶ ‘yellow peril’ refers to a particular combinatory kind of anticolonial [and¶ anti-West] nationalism, in which the union of Japanese technological¶ advance and Chinese numerical mass confronts Western civilization with¶ a potentially unbeatable force.”11 Arguably, the yellow peril of today represents¶ heightened Western anxieties around China’s combined forces of¶ population size, global economic growth, and rapid technological-scientific¶ innovation—all of which emerge from a political system that is considered¶ ideologically oppositional to ours. The current context, we suggest, is best¶ understood through the lens of techno-Orientalism.¶ When the idea of techno-Orientalism first appeared in David Morley¶ and Kevin Robins’s analysis of why Japan occupied such a threatening position¶ in Western imagination in the late 1980s, techno-Orientalism offered a framework to make sense of the technologically imbued racist stereotypes¶ of Japan/the Japanese that were emerging within the context of Western¶ fears and anxieties around Japan’s ascendancy as a technological global¶ power. They proposed that if technological advancement has been crucial¶ to Western civilizational progress, then Japan’s technological superiority¶ over the West also signals a critical challenge to Western hegemony,¶ including its cultural authority to control representations of the West and¶ its “others.” They claimed that the shifting balance in global power—the¶ West’s loss of technological preeminence—has induced an identity crisis in¶ the West. In response, techno-Orientalism, in which “[idioms of technology]¶ become structured into the discourse of Orientalism,” is produced in large¶ part to discipline Japan and its rise to techno-economic power.12 The United¶ States, for instance, externalized its anxiety into xenophobic projections of¶ Japan as a “culture that is cold, impersonal, and machine-like” in which its¶ people are “sub-human” and “unfeeling aliens.”13 Techno-Orientalism, born¶ from the “Japan Panic,” was effectively consolidated through and around¶ political-economic concerns that frame Japanese and, by extension, Asian¶ techno-capitalist progress as dangerous and dystopian.¶ Extending Edward Said’s concept of Orientalism,14 techno-Orientalism¶ marks a geo-historical shift where the West no longer has control over the¶ terms that define the East—the “Orient”—as weak, inferior, and subordinate¶ to the West. It marks a shift not only in political-economic power¶ but also in cultural authority. Techno-Orientalism, then, is the expressive¶ vehicle (cultural productions and visual representations) by which Western¶ and Eastern nations articulate their fears, desires, and anxieties that are¶ produced in their competitive struggle to gain technological hegemony¶ through economic trade and scientific innovation.15¶ Analogous to Japan’s position in the late 1980s, China currently figures¶ into the techno-Orientalist imaginary as a powerful competitor in mass¶ production, a global financial giant, and an aggressive investor in technological,¶ infrastructural, and scientific developments. At the same time,¶ the increasing purchasing power of China provokes American fear of a¶ future global market that is economically driven by Chinese consumptive¶ desires and practices. It is this duality—the domination of both production¶ and consumption across different sectors of the techno-capitalist global¶ economy—that undergirds American anxieties of a sinicized future.16 ¶ Further amplifying these anxieties around Chinese techno-economic¶ domination is our imagination of China/the Chinese as the ultimate yellow¶ peril, whose state ideology is oppositional to that of the United States and¶ whose unmatched population size combined with its economic expansion¶ and technological advancements may actually pose a real challenge to U.S.¶ global hegemony. We turn now to examine how the ideology of yellow¶ peril is manifesting in the current context of techno-Orientalism, beginning¶ first with an analysis of the racial trope of “Chinese as contagion” and its¶ connection to anti-Asian aggression.¶ The Racialized Contagion¶ The recent exponential rise of anti-Asian violence in the United States and¶ globally during the pandemic illustrates the persistent danger of racializing¶ diseases. Historians and social critics have documented and traced the ways¶ in which diseases have been continually racialized by their association with¶ particular peoples in geographical regions. Examples in recent memory¶ include SARS marked as Asian, MERS as Middle Eastern, Ebola as African,¶ and so on. In regards to this current pandemic, it might be useful to recall¶ the popularization of the “Chinese as contagion” trope in U.S. history, as¶ its multiple afterlives continue to inform the public’s facile acceptance of¶ the notion of Chinese as diseased bodies and pathogenic carriers. The late¶ nineteenth century racialization of the smallpox outbreak in San Francisco¶ serves as the antecedent to the current moment and illustrates its relationship¶ to the broader context of the anti-Chinese movement.