Modern Monetary Theory leads to inflation and wrecks the economy.
Roberts 22 [Lance Roberts, Chief Investment Strategist for RIA Advisors and Lead Editor of the Real Investment Report, July 23 2022, MMT Policy Was Tried, And It Failed, Seeking Alpha, https://seekingalpha.com/article/4525331-mmt-policy-was-tried-and-it-failed]
MMT Policy (Modern Monetary Theory), the grand experiment, was tried following the pandemic-driven shutdown of the economy. It failed miserably. However, before we get to its failure, we need to review the policy to understand why it failed to work as anticipated. According to Investopedia: The central idea of MMT is that governments with a fiat currency system under their control can and should print (or create with a few keystrokes in today's digital age) as much money as they need to spend because they cannot go broke or be insolvent unless a political decision to do so is taken. Some say such spending would be fiscally irresponsible, as the debt would balloon and inflation would skyrocket. But according to MMT: Large government debt isn't the precursor to a collapse that we believe it is; Countries like the U.S. can sustain much more significant deficits without cause for concern; and A small deficit or surplus can be extremely harmful and cause a recession since deficit spending is what builds people's savings. Here is the critical paragraph: According to MMT, the only limit that the government has when it comes to spending is the availability of real resources, like workers, construction supplies, etc. When government spending is too great with respect to the resources available, inflation can surge if decision-makers are not careful. Taxes create an ongoing demand for currency and are a tool to take money out of an economy that is getting overheated, says MMT. This goes against the conventional idea that taxes are primarily meant to provide the government with money to spend to build infrastructure, fund social welfare programs, etc. With this base understanding, we can "review the tape" to judge whether MMT was successful in its implementation as an economic policy tool. At the end of 2019, Federal Debt outstanding was $23.2 trillion. Of course, three months later, the government would decide to shut down the economy to battle the COVID-19 outbreak. That decision was the defining moment that implemented MMT policy with successive rounds of monetary stimulus from direct checks to households to expanded government subsidies. By the year-end of 2021, Federal Debt swelled to nearly $30 trillion. Such is the most significant increase in government spending in U.S. history. While the spending of a massive flood of stimulus temporarily boosted economic growth by “pulling forward” future demand, it also created several problems. The most obvious problem was the impact of dramatically increasing demand on a supply-stricken economy. With the economy “shut down” due to government-mandated restrictions, the flood of stimulus payments led to a demand boost. Given the basic economics of supply versus demand, prices rose. As expected, would be the case, the implementation led to a massive surge of inflation. (Given most Americans’ have fixed healthcare and housing payments for a contractual period, the third measure shows what cost-of-living is for most every month.) Such is always the problem of injecting money into the economic system. The repeated argument that more stimulus helps the “poor working class” is erroneous. As we argued in “Bidens Stimulus Will Cut Poverty For One Year,” when you provide “free” money, those that provide the products and services lift prices accordingly. A recent study shows this impact. “An analysis by the Penn Wharton Budget Model found that low- and middle-income households spent about 7% more in 2021 for the same products they bought in 2020 or 2019, an average of about $3,500,” according to the report. In other words, when you provide “free capital,” a market-based economy will adjust prices to compensate for the additional demand for products and services. Those primarily living paycheck-to-paycheck see their “disposable incomes” getting “taxed” away. Such leaves their standard of living unchanged. The following graph shows the average American now has a record deficit requiring more than $4,500 of new debt annually. Such is why socialism in any form does not elevate the middle class but shrinks it.While MMT proponents suggest that giving free money will boost economic equality, the opposite is the case, as shown by the net worth of the top 10 percent versus the bottom 50 percent of the population.