Capitalist AI is uniquely dangerous – creates surveillance capitalism and counterbalancing forces don’t exist.
Acemoglu and Johnson 23 [Daron Acemoglu is a Professor of Economics in the Department of Economics at MIT and affiliated with the National Bureau Economic Research, and the Center for Economic Policy Research. He is a Fellow of the National Academy of Sciences, the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, the Econometric Society, the Society of Labor Economists, and more. He received a BA in economics from the University of York, an MSc in mathematical economics and econometrics from the London School of Economics, and a PhD in economics from the London School of Economics. He is the author of various books that have won several prizes and his academic work has been published in leading scholarly journals. He has received numerous awards and fellowships (Sherwin Rosen Award; the Global Economy Prize; John Bates Clark Medal; the Erwin Plein Nemmers; BBVA Frontiers of Knowledge award. Simon Johnson is a Professor of Entrepreneurship at MIT. He was chief economist at the International Monetary Fund, and he currently co-chairs the CFA Institute Systemic Risk Council. Johnson was a senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics, a member of the Congressional Budget Office’s Panel of Economic Advisors, and a member of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation’s Systemic Resolution Advisory Committee. Johnson was a member of the Financial Research Advisory Committee of the U.S. Treasury’s Office of Financial Research. His research papers are widely cited, “Big Tech Is Bad. Big A.I. Will Be Worse,” The New York Times, 6-9-2023, https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/09/opinion/ai-big-tech-microsoft-google-duopoly.html, accessed 7-18-2023, HKR-SWY]
With the emergence of A.I., we are about to regress even further. Some of this has to do with the nature of the technology. Instead of assessing multiple sources, people are increasingly relying on the nascent technology to provide a singular, supposedly definitive answer. There is no easy way to access the footnotes or links that let users explore the underlying sources.
This technology is in the hands of two companies that are philosophically rooted in the notion of “machine intelligence,” which emphasizes the ability of computers to outperform humans in specific activities. Deep Mind, a company now owned by Google, is proud of developing algorithms that can beat human experts at games such as chess and Go.
This philosophy was naturally amplified by a recent (bad) economic idea that the singular objective of corporations should be to maximize short-term shareholder wealth. Combined together, these ideas are cementing the notion that the most productive applications of A.I. replace humankind. Doing away with grocery store clerks in favor of self-checkout kiosks does very little for the productivity of those who remain employed, for example, while also annoying many customers. But it makes it possible to fire workers and tilt the balance of power further in favor of management.
We believe the A.I. revolution could even usher in the dark prophecies envisioned by Karl Marx over a century ago. The German philosopher was convinced that capitalism naturally led to monopoly ownership over the “means of production” and that oligarchs would use their economic clout to run the political system and keep workers poor.
Fortunately, Marx was wrong about the 19th-century industrial age that he inhabited. Industries emerged much faster than he expected, and new firms disrupted the economic power structure. Countervailing social powers developed in the form of trade unions and genuine political representation for a broad swath of society. And governments developed the ability to regulate industrial excesses. The result was greater competition, higher wages and more robust democracies.
Today, those countervailing forces either don’t exist or are greatly weakened. Generative A.I. requires even deeper pockets than textile factories and steel mills. As a result, most of its obvious opportunities have already fallen into the hands of Microsoft, with its market capitalization of $2.4 trillion, and Alphabet, worth $1.6 trillion.
At the same time, powers like trade unions have been weakened by 40 years of deregulation ideology (Ronald Reagan, Margaret Thatcher, two Bushes and even Bill Clinton). For the same reason, the U.S. government’s ability to regulate anything larger than a kitten has withered. Extreme polarization and fear of killing the golden (donor) goose or undermining national security mean that most members of Congress would still rather look away.
To prevent data monopolies from ruining our lives, we need to mobilize effective countervailing power — and fast.