Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Calls to repair fit within a political project of methodological cosmopolitanism. To be a nation-state means to be an international political body suggesting it is appropriate to discuss global issues contextually, ie. Understanding the legacy of slavery in America means understanding America’s role in the global system of racial capitalism.

Magali Bessone, 02-22-2017, Bessone is Professor of political philosophy at Panthéon-Sorbonne University, member of the ISJPS (Institut des Sciences Juridique et Philosophique de la Sorbonne, UMR 8103) and associate researcher at Centre International de Recherche sur l’Esclavage et les Post-esclavages focusing on theories of justice and critical theories of race and racism, “From Reparations for Slavery to International Racial Justice: A Critical Republican Perspective”, GLOBAL JUSTICE : THEORY PRACTICE RHETORIC, https://doi.org/10.21248/gjn.9.2.117 // VDR

However, listening to the agents’ normative claims does not imply that we should necessarily endorse these claims. Moreover, marginalised agents may have competing claims: dominated groups are not univocal. Therefore, from a methodological perspective, critical republicanism’s diagnosis and formulation of such injustices requires close collaboration between normative theory on one hand and sociological, juridical and historical empirical analyses on the other. Sociological, legal and historical examination is necessary to explore and expose the reality of the domination actually experienced by actors in different spheres as well as the specific dimension of idealisation in all our normative ideals.18 In Cécile Laborde’s terms,19 critical republicanism, if it indicates sustaining the priority of injustice and working toward non-domination, has to test ‘official’ republican norms or ideals against empirical facts to demonstrate how these ideals were genealogically constructed and how they sometimes sociologically as factors in oppression or exclusion. Moreover, I suggest that such a critical republican theory leads us to a specific understanding of some global issues that are distinctively ‘international.’ This is different from current dominant paradigms — in particular, from the ‘methodological nationalism’ adopted by the tenants of what Laborde labels ‘official republicanism,’20 as well as from what David Miller refers to as ‘strong cosmopolitanism.’21 Following Isabelle Delpla, I propose to name this form of non-individualistic methodological cosmopolitanism ‘methodological internationalism.’22 It implies both that states remain primary agents of international justice (they matter for historical reasons) and that they should prima facie be understood as international entities operating within the framework of international law. This view retains from methodological nationalism the idea that nation-states are fundamental agents of global justice. However, it agrees with methodological cosmopolitanism as it recognises that states are inherently embedded in an international system of norms. Nation-states are part of an international order that has foreign policy implications: other states, or international institutions and organisations, inevitably influence their internal decisions. More significantly, however, methodological internationalism highlights that international circumstances are an essential part of the domestic ‘circumstances of politics’ where we assess which principles of justice should structure our social settings and institutions. Principles of justice always have both national and international implications — there is nothing like a strictly domestic principle of justice. The significance of nation-states in matters of justice can thus be both acknowledged and deeply revised: to be a nation-state means to be an international political body. Such methodological internationalism has two important epistemic consequences. First, it becomes not only possible but also appropriate to discuss global issues contextually. The meaning and significance of global political problems vary according to the perspective adopted, the public culture and the social norms of the political entity in which they are framed. This suggests that no political issue can simply be envisaged as a domestic issue and injustices in redistribution, recognition or representation always have an international dimension.23 Second, such an approach pleads for a dynamic — transitional — self-understanding of political entities. It recognises that even those republican polities, such as France, that view themselves as essentially close-bounded and homogenous communities, have created this representation of themselves in an actively promoted domestic political myth, which involved denying their inherently international character. In official republicanism, our core national identity is supposed to have emerged ‘from within’ the nation rather than primarily from (a constant interaction with) international norms and procedures. Hence, identifying the nation-state as a constitutively international entity could lead us to support the view of the French republic as a more open and pluralist body: it promotes the possibility of an effective change in the self-representation of French national identity. This endeavour is, in contrast to official republicanism, an important challenge for critical republicanism. For these methodological reasons, I suggest that the effort to prioritise injustices, coupled with a focus on their meaning in specific contexts whose national character is already international, can prove to be a heuristically useful manner of grasping global justice issues. Such contextualised theorisation allows us to develop a better understanding and more precise account of how new forms of injustice emerge from certain socio-historical relations within and across polities and how these are framed in situated languages or grammars that reveal the tension between their supposedly national, and really international, character. The ‘Official Republican’ Perspective on ReparationsReparations for colonial slavery have recently been prominent in the French public sphere. The demand for reparations appeared both as part of an international trend, precipitated by the UNESCO World Conference Against Racism in Durban in 2001, where African and Caribbean delegations set the agenda on reparations, and in the national context of the (first) ‘Taubira law’ (2001)24 which recognised slavery and the slave trade as ‘crimes against humanity.’ The activist group Conseil Représentatif des Associations Noires (CRAN) called for a national debate on reparations in 2012 and 2013. Although this was rejected by the French state,25 it was largely publicised in the media; however, it aroused both misunderstanding and opposition.26 Reparations are perceived as an expression of the ‘memory war’27 that has been raging in France since the late 1990s and was particularly virulent in 2005–2006 after the so-called ‘riots’ in the suburbs of Paris. This war is all the more acute because it affects the national identity narrative, in which unity and coherency is perceived to be threatened due to colonial fracture and the possible recognition of a criminal past.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.