The 1AC takes a picture in an ongoing global transfer. This allows for survival strategies- taking consequential action based on improving the lives of people here and now allows for an improvement of material conditions in the short run.
Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò, 11-2022, Táíwò’s theoretical work draws liberally from the Black radical tradition, anti-colonial thought, German transcendental philosophy, contemporary philosophy of language, contemporary social science, and histories of activism and activist thinkers, “Reconsidering Reparations”, Oxford University Press // VDR
Heyd takes a snapshot of the present distribution of industrializa- tion between current nation-states and casually projects an entirely fic- titious history of parallel development, as though none of these nations ever interacted with each other. The facts determining which countries participated in the Industrial Revolution are not matters of “luck” or “intellectual tradition.” Moreover, “initiative” seems an odd descrip- tion for a moral philosopher to give to the European empires’ choices to employ human trafficking, elimination of Indigenous populations, and colonial expropriation and domination on a global scale to fuel their local development of industry and accumulation of profit. I doubt that Heyd or other thinkers adopting the “general Rawlsian view” re- ally mean to characterize mass enslavement and genocide as “initi- ative.” I suspect, rather, that, focused on the snapshot of the present, they consider these issues only as an afterthought, if at all.
I think we should take a historical view of distributive justice. On a historical view of distributive justice, we are still concerned about the problems with current distributions of justice on purely consequential grounds, based on the differences they make in the lives of the people here and now. But we also understand the nature of the here and now. ‘Here’ is a place in a global system, and ‘now’ is a moment in an ongoing global transfer that does not pause just because we took a picture.
We should intervene in distributions of goods, resources, and rights in order to make people’s lives better and improve the fairness of institutions in the short run. We should intervene so that the global system distributing advantages and disadvantages to our own chil- dren, grandchildren, and great-grandchildren works for them more justly. We should also be concerned with present distributions as the moral sediment of unjust processes, or even as the continued moral life of those processes. Global racial empire, and its history of slavery and colonial domination, will be fully conquered only when their effects on the accumulation of advantages and disadvantages are also conquered.