d. Jobs would be impossible to find
Max Gulker 18, Senior Research Fellow at the American Institute for Economic Research, 10-01-2018, " The Job Guarantee: A Critical Analysis," American Institute for Economic Research, https://www.aier.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/JobGuarantee_0.pdf //MRK
An employer normally pays an employee because the latter is doing something of value. Under a federal job guarantee, that logic is reversed: the government must find something for ten million or more workers to do because they are being paid. The difference is of great importance.
The work handed out under a job guarantee is subject to complex criteria. In the view of the Levy report, these jobs must
• Be able to “quickly accommodate new entrants into the program and let them go without disruption should they find alternative employment”
• Help low-skilled workers build human capital to “enhance their chances to obtain work outside the program. They will gain work experience as well as on-the-job training.”
• In every community, “provide visible benefits, meeting specific local needs”
• Put millions to work “without competing for employees or displacing private sector undertakings” or “conventional public-sector work”
These points, taken together, are astonishing.14 The work given to enrollees must teach valuable skills, but not so valuable that someone securely employed in the private sector would want to enroll. And while the work needs to result in “visible benefits,” these benefits should not be so great that any firm or government agency would be willing on its own to pay a wage of fifteen dollars per hour.15