Congress will impose limits on eligibility---turns the case.
Matt Bruenig 20, American lawyer, blogger, policy analyst, commentator, and founder of the left-leaning think tank People's Policy Project, “Matt Bruenig Debates Job Guarantee with Mark Paul,” People’s Policy Project, 11/2/20, https://www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2020/11/02/matt-bruenig-debates-job-guarantee-with-mark-paul/
The job guarantee favored by Paul is a basic unemployment benefit that has very strict work requirements, also known as “workfare.” In opposing this kind of program, I offer the alternative of an unemployment benefit with generous income replacement and a decent minimum benefit that has very few conditions attached to it.
The problem with attaching strict conditions to benefit receipt is that many people will fail to meet those conditions and thereby lose their benefits, causing poverty, hunger, and homelessness. Even those who manage to jump through the hoops and perform their required hours of community service have to suffer through hassle and time wastes to do so. Our experience with workfare in the US, most famously with the NYC Work Experience Program, has also been very negative.
After my initial point, the remainder of my contributions took the form of rebutting points Paul raised. Below are some of the back and forth, summarized briefly.
Paul brought up the issue of poverty. But you solve poverty through the welfare state not through workfare per se. We can see this clearly in the comparison between the US and Finland. In 2016, Finland’s poverty rate was about one-third of the US poverty rate even as their overall employment rate was 1 percentage point lower than the employment rate in the US. Also, to the extent that the “job guarantee” lowers poverty, it is because of the cash unemployment benefit it provides recipients not the community service it requires the recipients to do.