A Carbon tax is the only way to solve for climate change no other policy solves.
Shi Ling 21 .Hsu, Shi-Ling. Shi-Ling Hsu is the D'Alemberte Professor of Law at the Florida State University College of Law” Carbon Taxes and Economic Inequality.” Harvard Law & Policy Review. January 5, 2021. https://ssrn.com/abstract=3760667 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3760667 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3760667
Carbon taxation has become a central, if understated component of a comprehensive program to address climate change. A carbon tax is a unitary tax on emissions of carbon dioxide, and potentially other greenhouse gases that warm the climate, targeted almost exclusively on the combustion of fossil fuels. While economists have universally endorsed the idea of a carbon tax,1 it remains politically challenging for lawmakers to enact one.2 Besides opposition from those denying the significance of climate change,3 there is surprisingly tepid support from progressive groups concerned with social and economic justice, in addition to climate change.4 Progressive ambivalence about carbon taxation is both understandable and misplaced. It is understandable because carbon taxation is widely believed to be regressive.5 It has become standard fare that a carbon tax increases energy costs, which makes up a larger portion of a poor household's budget than a rich one.6 As it turns out, this is probably a misperception : carbon taxes actually hurt fossil fuel industries, which are owned by relatively wealthy shareholders, more than they injure consumers.7 Moreover, carbon tax revenues can, and should, be redistributed in such a way that overcompensates most poor households for increased energy costs (resulting from carbon taxation) and undercompensates most rich households, in which case some progress can be made towards economic equality. All that said, however, that redistribution would be fairly modest at the carbon tax levels that are currently under discussion – on the order of a few hundred or a few thousand dollars per household, annually.8 So at best, carbon taxation can only advance modest gains towards greater equality.
At the same time, progressive ambivalence about carbon taxation is also misplaced because climate change itself is the ultimate un-equalizer, amplifying economic inequality to potentially apocalyptic extremes. The most important policy that can be adopted to stave off climate change, as much as possible, is a carbon tax. Without a broad price in the form of a carbon tax, it will be impossible to induce the uncountably many changes that must be made to wean humankind off fossil fuel usage. Conventional environmental laws and regulations can accomplish much, and in any case are needed to fill the gaps left by a carbon tax. But without a policy foundation in the form of a carbon price, the necessary scale of changes will not occur. Carbon taxation is thus a critically important component for economic justice, just by virtue of being the most important policy to minimize climate change. While carbon taxation has only modest potential to advance economic justice, it is critical for minimizing the backsliding that would inevitably occur in a climate-changed future. The case for a carbon tax for the sake of economic justice is thus compelling, if nonobvious. It is important to recognize, as some justice advocates seem to recognize or intuit, that the core goals of carbon taxation and economic justice seem to point in different, though not opposite directions: the preservation of human civilization and the reform of human civilization. However, both of those goals require economic reform, and it so happens that carbon taxation is effective reform for advancing policy in both of those directions. Most importantly, reforming human civilization to achieve economic justice depends upon saving human civilization from climate change. Without that there is no justice for anyone at all.